Re:Gun-related deaths and suicides among American children s...
by jimt1234 on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @04:34PM
(#37757180)
tl;dr = I think we should all be skeptical of any gun-related data in the US.
I don't doubt the narrative in the article, but I'm skeptical about the data used. For years, my impression has been that gun advocates in the US have done everything they can to prevent any sort of data collection and/or analysis wrt to anything related to guns (ownership, usage, and gun-related deaths). I think this is based on the fear that the data will be used to take everyone's guns (either the FBI will start kicking down doors and seizing guns, or law makers will use the data to help pass gun restrictions). Furthermore, I don't know much about the CDC's "WONDER" database, but I can see where a gun-related death could be reported simply as an "accidental death" or something like that in certain counties, and as such, that wouldn't show up as gun-related in the "WONDER" data.
I don't doubt the narrative in the article, but I'm skeptical about the data used. For years, my impression has been that gun advocates in the US have done everything they can to prevent any sort of data collection and/or analysis wrt to anything related to guns (ownership, usage, and gun-related deaths). I think this is based on the fear that the data will be used to take everyone's guns (either the FBI will start kicking down doors and seizing guns, or law makers will use the data to help pass gun restrictions). Furthermore, I don't know much about the CDC's "WONDER" database, but I can see where a gun-related death could be reported simply as an "accidental death" or something like that in certain counties, and as such, that wouldn't show up as gun-related in the "WONDER" data.