News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: Google Plus doesn't like my name by orp on Friday March 30, 2012 @08:34AM (#3775619)
Oh, I realize that. I even agree with their reasoning.

I just don't like the fact that their algorithm is so bad that I came up as a false positive. Algorithms is the one place you don't expect Google to fail.

I mean, come on, the have thousands of my emails, my geolocation, my facebook profile is public, and they can't figure out Or is my real name?

Re:Tell HN: Google Plus doesn't like my name by read_wharf on Friday March 30, 2012 @09:13AM (#3775747)
They haven't failed. They have a huge body of identified individuals that they can sell to advertisers, efficiently and economically harvested.

Oh, they failed at individual user service? What farmer is concerned about an individual cabbage? It would cost way to much to get down off the truck and carefully retrieve the few units that rolled off the truck.

There is absolutely no failure here. None.

Re:Tell HN: Google Plus doesn't like my name by babarock on Friday March 30, 2012 @09:35AM (#3775833)
I believe what the OP is saying here is "failure" occurred not on a strategic corporate level, but on a computer-science-algorithm-geek level. He hasn't disclose his full name, so we cannot fully judge, but how would you react if "Joe Smith" came out as a false positive?

Of all the crazy things we're hearing about Google lately, failure on an algorithmic level may be the last thing we expect.

Then again, maybe the name is indeed more subtle than the OP seems to think...

Re:Tell HN: Google Plus doesn't like my name by read_wharf on Friday March 30, 2012 @09:47AM (#3775886)
And I'm saying that the algorithm is imperfect by design, and accepted as such, because perfection would cost too much in computing and human resources.

You cannot fail a cabbage.

Re:Tell HN: Google Plus doesn't like my name by monkeypizza on Friday March 30, 2012 @12:13PM (#3776680)
I'm sure cabbage truck designers pay a lot of attention to the cabbage loss rate... Look how much effort was put into the design of shipping containers.
Re:Tell HN: Google Plus doesn't like my name by muchonada on Friday March 30, 2012 @10:54AM (#3776195)
> What farmer is concerned about an individual cabbage?

What a great analogy! We don't think twice about the farmer leaving a few cabbages out in the field, but we get all up in arms when we realize that we are that cabbage.

Re:Tell HN: Google Plus doesn't like my name by someoneorother on Friday March 30, 2012 @10:55AM (#3776199)
OMG, a talking cabbage!
Re:Tell HN: Google Plus doesn't like my name by gbog on Friday March 30, 2012 @09:43AM (#3775863)
> Algorithms is the one place you don't expect Google to fail

Maybe this thing (the reality of names) is not rationalisable, and therefore not modelizable with an algorithm. For instance, I know someone who has chosen the name of a Russian president has his nickname, and I guarantee you it is not his real name. How would Google detect that? On the opposite, "Ng" is a perfectly valid surname in Southern Chinese, and it really looks like a nick...