Having recently read "How We Decide", I can't help but think many of the traps described in that book are hit heavily by those trying to pick a programming language.
That may be true but is it really informative? Apples to apples: pick equivalent ultra-picky-with-membership team of talented programmers and then compare their artifacts' maintainability. C is a fine language but the point of Java is that it lowers the bar (by dealing with hard problems e.g. GC) and makes it more accessible (look ma, no pointers).
A possibly controversial (but arguably viable) measure of "Java and friends" success is the explosion of "complexity" in software written in these languages. My thesis is that IT league programmers would not have ventured to take spectacular architectural spacewalks in C or C++ but felt completely comfortable doing so in (say) Java.
I'm not even going to go into why, it's been said a million times. Let's just agree that you've got an opinion that's not particularly compelling or common to a lot of experienced programmers. Your 'beauty' is many other people's bane. The very things you've picked out can cause such complexity and pain.