News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tech Culture: More Legos and Less Punch Buggy by yummyfajitas on Thursday March 29, 2012 @07:37PM (#3773722)
If you’ve not been a minority in a group before (especially in a career-type setting), then it is hard to even imagine what that’s like.

First of all, lets call this argument out for what it is - it's basically an appeal to authority. It's an implicit claim that if you aren't a member of a specific authoritative group, you are unable to reason about a topic. And it's a logical fallacy.

Second of all, it isn't even true. I've been a minority in a career-type setting ever since leaving academia and I've never had the reactions that the author's whiny male friend did. People mock me due to my unusual physical characteristics (e.g., I get sunburned), I mock them for being < 5' tall, then we get lunch.

It's no big deal because I choose to focus on the code, relax and roll with it.

But hey, I'm sure my experience will be dismissed because I'm not the right type of minority in a career setting.

Re:Tech Culture: More Legos and Less Punch Buggy by MartinCron on Thursday March 29, 2012 @07:54PM (#3773793)
I think you're kind of proving the author's point. You don't get hurt in those scenarios, therefore you think nobody does or nobody should.

Not everyone can be, or even should be, exactly the same.

Re:Tech Culture: More Legos and Less Punch Buggy by yummyfajitas on Thursday March 29, 2012 @08:03PM (#3773828)
I'm not disputing the author's main point. I'm pointing out a logical fallacy in their post.
Re:Tech Culture: More Legos and Less Punch Buggy by MartinCron on Thursday March 29, 2012 @08:14PM (#3773871)
It's only a logical fallacy if you stretch it too far. The original statement was that "it's hard to know what something's like if you haven't experienced it" which is a perfectly reasonable thing to say, along the lines of "you haven't had salted caramel ice cream? You don't know what you're missing!"

You distorted that into "unless you are a member of the group, it's impossible for you to understand" which I guess would be a logical fallacy, but that's a different message altogether.

Re:Tech Culture: More Legos and Less Punch Buggy by liamcampbell on Thursday March 29, 2012 @07:52PM (#3773783)
"It's no big deal because I choose to focus on the code, relax and roll with it."

It's cool that you can take the prejudice you are dealt, but some people surely get worse than you. I'm not dismissing your experience, I'm just pointing out that it is merely YOUR experience. You (like everyone) can't speak for all minority groups.

Re:Tech Culture: More Legos and Less Punch Buggy by icegreentea on Thursday March 29, 2012 @09:42PM (#3774111)
You're arguing personal anecdote (experience) against another one. Which is exactly what this article was about. While you cannot point to one person who belongs to a minority whos having some trouble and extrapolate that to the entire population of minority, neither can your counter example disprove the reverse statement. Logically speaking, one example of discrimination proves that "at least one person of this minority group is discriminated against" which leaves the stronger statement "many people of this minority group are discriminated against", while the negative (your experience) can only state that "not all people of this minority group are discriminated against", which strictly speaking isn't refuting the original point at all, since very few people are confident enough of their data to argue that all people of a minority are discriminated against.