News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Poll: What is your current Stack Overflow reputation? by cruise02 on Thursday March 29, 2012 @04:22PM (#3772936)
> overzealous mods shutting down my questions in the most condescending tone possible.

SO moderator here. We just click a link. The pre-defined close reasons are inserted automatically. No one is taking a tone with you.

Re:Poll: What is your current Stack Overflow reputation? by cowkingdeluxe on Thursday March 29, 2012 @07:17PM (#3773640)
The comments moderators post are pretty condescending. They turned me off from SO. Not to mention the condescending nature of your comment here.
Re:Poll: What is your current Stack Overflow reputation? by cruise02 on Thursday March 29, 2012 @07:21PM (#3773653)
After calling us overzealous and condescending do you expect a hug?
Re:Poll: What is your current Stack Overflow reputation? by rbarooah on Friday March 30, 2012 @05:34AM (#3775122)
The fact that you use automation to produce your responses doesn't make you any less responsible for them.
Re:Poll: What is your current Stack Overflow reputation? by cruise02 on Friday March 30, 2012 @08:04AM (#3775524)
I'm not shirking responsibility for putting the responses there. I'm saying that they aren't condescending. The messages are to inform people why their question was closed and to help them improve it.
Re:Poll: What is your current Stack Overflow reputation? by rbarooah on Friday March 30, 2012 @08:43AM (#3775653)
If the messages are written in a tone that people generally find condescending, then they are condescending. The intent may be positive but doesn't change the impact of the writing style.

As a matter of interest, do these template responses make it clear that they are indeed templates and not hand written?

Re:Poll: What is your current Stack Overflow reputation? by cruise02 on Friday March 30, 2012 @09:17AM (#3775762)
They're not inserted as comments, but as a block of text that's offset from the rest of the post, so I think it's pretty clear that they're auto-inserted. You can search the site for "closed:1" to find questions with different messages that get inserted.

http://stackoverflow.com/search?q=closed%3A1

Re:Poll: What is your current Stack Overflow reputation? by rbarooah on Friday March 30, 2012 @11:32AM (#3776419)
Fair enough - it does look obvious to me that those are automatic 'rubber stamps'.

They don't read as particularly condescending to me, but I imagine that if one was used in error or with questionable judgement it might well come off that way.

Is there any mechanism for quality control on how they are used?

Re:Poll: What is your current Stack Overflow reputation? by cruise02 on Friday March 30, 2012 @01:14PM (#3777000)
There is some control over how they're used. In most cases it takes 5 users with at least 3000 reputation to vote to close a question. The close reason that the majority selected is the one that gets displayed. Moderators (and employees of Stack Exchange) can close questions with a single vote if they're flagged, but we generally try to encourage people to use close votes if they have that ability.

Also, any closed question can be reopened by community vote whether it was closed by a moderator or by voting.

Re:Poll: What is your current Stack Overflow reputation? by justncase80 on Friday March 30, 2012 @12:20PM (#3776707)
It doesn't seem condescending to me, I think the people being moderated are just taking it too personally and can't believe that they unwittingly committed a faux pas.
Re:Poll: What is your current Stack Overflow reputation? by georgieporgie on Thursday March 29, 2012 @04:40PM (#3773003)
We just click a link

Comments.

No one is taking a tone with you.

Oh, the irony.

Re:Poll: What is your current Stack Overflow reputation? by cruise02 on Thursday March 29, 2012 @07:28PM (#3773674)
Comments. What about them? The close message is auto-inserted so we don't have to take the time to comment.

Irony, no. My tone here is a response to being called overzealous and condescending. It has nothing to do with my attitude when I'm acting as moderator on SO.

Re:Poll: What is your current Stack Overflow reputation? by georgieporgie on Friday March 30, 2012 @12:03AM (#3774456)
I don't understand why you seem to be attempting to speak for all moderators. I don't know or care what your attitude is about moderation, I'm speaking of my own personal experience with SO moderators.
Re:Poll: What is your current Stack Overflow reputation? by cruise02 on Friday March 30, 2012 @06:49AM (#3775314)
Provide some links, please.
Re:Poll: What is your current Stack Overflow reputation? by ycedmart on Friday April 06, 2012 @09:43PM (#3809675)
There's no need for anyone to provide links. A lot of people are complaining about this. And as soon as anyone tries to post in meta about this issue (the issue of mods over-zealously closing questions), these posts in meta get downvoted to no avail and there's a flamefest of "high horse" posts... By mods! Constantly defending themselves, just like you do here. It's always the same "link or it didn't happen" and then the exact same "oh but I wasn't using a 'tone' here". Yes you were. And you know it. And several people here agree...
Re:Poll: What is your current Stack Overflow reputation? by cruise02 on Sunday April 08, 2012 @11:59AM (#3814101)
"Link or it didn't happen" is a perfectly valid response to empty complaints that provide no evidence. As a moderator I'm in a position to actually do something about real problems. If you just whine and complain without giving me a link I can't do anything about it.

No, I wasn't taking a tone. If I was I wouldn't say that I wasn't. If you perceived a tone, it's on your end. I'd thank you to not call me a liar.

Re:Poll: What is your current Stack Overflow reputation? by georgieporgie on Friday March 30, 2012 @03:01PM (#3777539)
I'm not linking my online identities.
Re:Poll: What is your current Stack Overflow reputation? by ycedmart on Friday April 06, 2012 @09:45PM (#3809677)
And you don't have to. And you do not have to answer to that SO mod's request here for several people here agree with you and know you're not making this up.
Re:Poll: What is your current Stack Overflow reputation? by lhnn on Thursday March 29, 2012 @08:47PM (#3773968)
That word: I don't think it means what you think it means.
Re:Poll: What is your current Stack Overflow reputation? by compay on Thursday March 29, 2012 @09:27PM (#3774081)
Sorry, no grammar cop points for you. That was a correct usage of the word "irony."
Re:Poll: What is your current Stack Overflow reputation? by Laxman13 on Friday March 30, 2012 @09:53AM (#3775909)
Not sure the point was to be grammar cop. I, at least, took it as a line from The Princess Bride (http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0093779/quotes?qt=qt0482717)
Re:Poll: What is your current Stack Overflow reputation? by lhnn on Friday March 30, 2012 @07:09PM (#3778585)
No, it wasn't. Either he was implying the SO mod was being inappropriate (wrong), or he used the word incorrectly.
Re:Poll: What is your current Stack Overflow reputation? by compay on Friday March 30, 2012 @07:16PM (#3778599)
>>> in the most condescending tone possible.

>> No one is taking a tone with you.

> Oh, the irony.

Condescendingly telling someone "nobody is taking a tone with you." That's the irony you're missing.