News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Introduction to the evidential presumption that computers... by dan-robertson on Sunday October 01, 2023 @07:15AM (#37724815)
Do you think an increase in punishment the executives expected would have led to the problems for subpostmasters being resolved faster or slower?
Re:Introduction to the evidential presumption that computers... by fanf2 on Sunday October 01, 2023 @07:42AM (#37724983)
It doesn’t matter either way, they need to be punished for the way they treated the people who were under their power.
Re:Introduction to the evidential presumption that computers... by actionfromafar on Sunday October 01, 2023 @07:46AM (#37725010)
Will punishment cause time-travel, you mean? Probably not.
Re:Introduction to the evidential presumption that computers... by dan-robertson on Sunday October 01, 2023 @08:35AM (#37725347)
Consider it as either a counter factual or a question about similar events in future.
Re:Introduction to the evidential presumption that computers... by didntcheck on Sunday October 01, 2023 @07:53AM (#37725049)
Am I inferring correctly that you are suggesting I may cause a perverse incentive, wherein they would be more motivated to cover it up due to the potential of punishment? I don't think that applies, as the punishment I'm suggesting is for the cover-up and knowing prosecution of innocent people, so the incentive would be to not do that. Not to mention they already seemed fully motivated to continue saving face anyway

Having rich people face actual material consequences to their life, rather than "punishments" like losing a job or honor, would hopefully reduce corporate malpractice, yes, as they now know that they are not invincible (obligatory note that I am talking about criminal responsibility, not suggesting we do away with LLCs or something)

Re:Introduction to the evidential presumption that computers... by dan-robertson on Sunday October 01, 2023 @08:34AM (#37725334)
I think that might be an effect, but I’m not sure. If something like this were to happen again, the thing I would most want would be whatever rules would most speedily lead to any prosecutions against subpostmasters being sopped and any convictions being overturned (with just compensation for the wrongful convictions).

I think to achieve that it has to be better in expectancy for someone who knows about the problem (and widely believed by that person too) to act sooner to resolve the problem than to try to cover things up, but I don’t really know what rules would help. For example, maybe an alternative thing that would work would be some kind of whistleblower rules like in finance[1].

In the hypothetical where I am stood with my hand on the lever choosing between stopping the scandal sooner and letting executives off entirely or having more wrongful convictions for longer but later throwing the executives in jail, I will choose the former every time, even though it feels unjust.

[1] In finance the whistleblower rules are designed to incentivise people to not be accomplices to crimes done by their superiors/coworkers. The incentives must be high because, no matter what the rules say about it, whistleblowers will expect to not work in finance again after blowing the whistle. The rules work because those large-scale financial crimes generally are hard to without one’s competent colleagues finding out.

Re:Introduction to the evidential presumption that computers... by Spooky23 on Sunday October 01, 2023 @10:35AM (#37726309)
Your question makes a good point. Punishment is only effective at the bottom of the funnel.

A well designed system, whether a computer or an organization should always have controls that guide things to where they should be. That means carrots and sticks.

In a place like a post office, that means separation of duties, audit, and clear lines of accountability. Things fail when nobody asks awkward questions or looks.

I do think that leadership responsible for a debacle like this must be punished. Their incompetence destroyed lives of innocent people.

Re:Introduction to the evidential presumption that computers... by zzbn00 on Sunday October 01, 2023 @03:59PM (#37729967)
In principle there was already some separation of duty as solictors in England owe a duty to the Court regardless of who pays them. However it seems not to have been enough in this case. Hopefully will be looked into.
Re:Introduction to the evidential presumption that computers... by etothepii on Sunday October 01, 2023 @04:47PM (#37730559)
I think you mean barristers.

The problem here was that as many sub-postmasters were co owned by a husband and wife with children. There was an enormous incentive for one of the sub post masters to plead guilty and say, "my wife had nothing to do with it." Doubly so as the sentences would often be on the cusp of the "suspendible range", a guilty plea combined with contrition is much more likely to get a judge to suspend your sentence if he can.

Of course, this "plea-bargaining" is standard practice in the states but we aren't used to it in the UK.

The issue is that no barrister would allow their client to plead guilty without giving them a little canned speech about not pleading guilty if they didn't do it and having them, "sign their brief".

Re:Introduction to the evidential presumption that computers... by zzbn00 on Wednesday October 04, 2023 @06:07AM (#37763028)
I meant the solictor of the Post Office -- solicitors in England are both classified as officers of the court and owe duties to the Court. So amongst other things Post Office's own solicitors should have declined to act in any way that could mislead the court.