Re:A couple of messages about changes to ianVisits: Copyrigh...
by growt on Saturday September 30, 2023 @05:04AM
(#37713801)
There are real photographers enforcing their copyright, but there are also trolls. The trolls are pushing a few Fotos they made to Wikipedia and “free Foto”-sites with missing terms. Then they search for people who stole their images and extract money. Sure the people who used the images are in the wrong legally, but the trolls actually wanted their images to be stolen. Also, for the trolls, this is the only kind of revenue they get. Those images would never be legally bought or licensed anyway
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:A couple of messages about changes to ianVisits: Copyrigh...
by krisoft on Saturday September 30, 2023 @05:39AM
(#37713935)
> Those images would never be legally bought or licensed anyway
Why? If they are good enough that people choose to use them in their publications then why do you assert this?
Re:A couple of messages about changes to ianVisits: Copyrigh...
by efaref on Saturday September 30, 2023 @05:52AM
(#37713992)
We only know that they're good enough to be used for free, so all we can assert that their current value is $0.
Re:A couple of messages about changes to ianVisits: Copyrigh...
by Tomte on Saturday September 30, 2023 @06:05AM
(#37714058)
That the lower floor of the commercial value is zero.
Re:A couple of messages about changes to ianVisits: Copyrigh...
by VBprogrammer on Saturday September 30, 2023 @06:32AM
(#37714168)
> Then they search for people who stole their images and extract money.
I think part of this problem is that the assumed value of an image is practically 0. Conversely any YouTuber from some rural backwater will make sure there is no copyright music playing in the background of anything they intend to release because they know that it has non-0 value. The reason this changed is because people became more collectively aware of the consequences. The long term consequences are that people will ensure they have the appropriate permissions before using a photo. Even if this means paying a nearly negligible amount for access to collections of millions of photos like happens with music now.