News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Who Invented the Alphabet? by adastra22 on Saturday September 30, 2023 @03:52AM (#37713476)
Sometimes there are cercumflexed vowels that change pronunciation.

My assumption is that these vowels were accented, but you could only have one diacritic.

Re:Who Invented the Alphabet? by thaumasiotes on Saturday September 30, 2023 @08:44AM (#37714895)
Wikipedia says this about modern French spelling:

> An acute accent over ⟨e⟩ represents /e/

> A grave accent over ⟨e⟩ indicates /ɛ/ in positions where a plain ⟨e⟩ would be pronounced /ə/ (schwa).

> A circumflex over ⟨a, e, o⟩ indicates /ɑ, ɛ, o/, respectively, but the distinction between ⟨a⟩ /a/ vs. ⟨â⟩ /ɑ/ is being lost in Parisian French, merging them as [a]. In Belgian French, ⟨ê⟩ is pronounced [ɛː]. Most often, it indicates the historical deletion of an adjacent letter (usually ⟨s⟩ or a vowel): château < castel, fête < feste, sûr < seur, dîner < disner (in medieval manuscripts many letters were often written as diacritical marks, e.g. the circumflex for ⟨/s/⟩ and the tilde for ⟨/n/⟩).

What I can take from that (lacking detailed knowledge of French) is that ê always refers to the same vowel as è (with a length distinction in Belgian French), and sometimes, in contexts which defy simple description†, e refers to the same vowel. (The vowel in question is similar to that in the English word DRESS.) è is used to avoid the suggestion that a plain e might be read in the default way, as /ə/, and ê is used to remind you that the word used to contain an s.

It does not appear that a circumflex will generically clobber other accent information; the verb "listen" was formerly escouter and now, pronounced with /e/ and not /ɛ/, is spelled écouter according to the pronunciation rather than êcouter according to the etymology.

( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_orthography )

If you have a particular example in mind that the treatment of modern French doesn't seem to work for, Wikipedia also has a lot of material on sound changes between Latin and French: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phonological_history_of_French

† The page has a table of how to predict the pronunciation of unaccented "e". These are the listed exceptions to the default reading:

(a) "e" appears before multiple consonants, or before a double consonant, or before a silent consonant that is followed by t.

(b) "e" appears before a silent consonant that is not t and is not followed by t.

(c) "e" appears at the end of a word, except for some (but not all) one-syllable words. In some contexts, those non-exceptional one-syllable words will also be exceptions.

(d) "e" as it appears in the words et, femme (first position), solennel (first position), or any word ending in the suffix -emment (first position).

A context that doesn't match any of these exceptions, including the unspecified exceptions, calls for a grave accent over the e when the vowel is /ɛ/. Otherwise, you're good to just use e.

All this leaves me unenthusiastic about the concept of "make it easier to pronounce unfamiliar words by making your spelling more like French".

Re:Who Invented the Alphabet? by adastra22 on Sunday October 01, 2023 @12:30AM (#37722559)
> It does not appear that a circumflex will generically clobber other accent information; the verb "listen" was formerly escouter and now, pronounced with /e/ and not /ɛ/, is spelled écouter according to the pronunciation rather than êcouter according to the etymology.

This is what I was referring to. As a French learner (I just recently began the journey), you don't know whether to pronounce something as é, è, or e when you see a ê. And there's not generally a rule for figuring it out, at least not as far as I've encountered. For a native speaker this isn't really an issue, but as a learner it's quite annoying.

I recognize that those learning my native language, English, have a far worse time of it however.