Re:Tao Te Ching
by woopsn on Thursday September 28, 2023 @05:19PM
(#37696021)
So I have Mitchell's version and like it as well. But he notably did not call his piece a new translation, only a new version. He doesn't speak or read any Chinese[1], so to begin with he was studying from secondary sources. He also generally just rephrased and reworded liberally. It's his version of Tao Te Ching. To be fair this is the case for most "translations".
For example Mitchell begins #3:
If you overesteem great men,
people become powerless.
If you overvalue possessions,
people begin to steal.
While American sinologist Robert Henricks[2] translated it as:
By not elevating the worthy, you bring it about that people will not compete.
By not valuing goods that are hard to obtain, you bring it about that people will not act like thieves.
By not displaying the desirable you bring it about that people will not be confused.
And from Chinese jurist John C. H. WU[3]:
By not exalting the talented you will cause the people to cease from rivalry and contention.
By not prizing goods hard to get, you will cause the people to cease from robbing and stealing.
By not displaying what is desirable, you will cause the people's hearts to remain undisturbed.
Some of the changes are like this, Mitchell's version was more readable and familiar compared to the translations, compressing the message (which made it somewhat reductive). Note that he elided an entire sentence present in the original. He made edits like that throughout.
#9:
Fill your bowl to the brim
and it will spill.
Keep sharpening your knife
and it will blunt.
Chase after money and security
and your heart will never unclench.
Care about people's approval
and you will be their prisoner.
Do your work, then step back.
The only path to serenity.
Compare to Henricks:
To hold it upright and fill it,
Is not so good as stopping [in time].
When you pound it out and give it a point,
It won't be preserved very long.
When gold and jade fill your rooms,
You'll never be able to protect them.
Arrogance and pride with wealth and rank,
On their own bring on disaster.
When the deed is accomplished you retire;
Such is Heaven's Way!
And Wu:
As for holding to fullness,
Far better were it to stop in time!
Keep on beating and sharpening a sword,
And the edge cannot be preserved for long.
Fill your house with gold and jade,
And it can no longer be guarded.
Set store by your riches and honour,
And you will only reap a crop of calamities.
Here is the Way of Heaven:
When you have done your work, retire!
The examples are fundamentally different, more linear, and less Chinese. Mitchell interprets Tao as the way to serenity, rather than the Way of Heaven.
For example Mitchell begins #3:
While American sinologist Robert Henricks[2] translated it as: And from Chinese jurist John C. H. WU[3]: Some of the changes are like this, Mitchell's version was more readable and familiar compared to the translations, compressing the message (which made it somewhat reductive). Note that he elided an entire sentence present in the original. He made edits like that throughout.#9:
Compare to Henricks: And Wu: The examples are fundamentally different, more linear, and less Chinese. Mitchell interprets Tao as the way to serenity, rather than the Way of Heaven.[1] https://scott.london/interviews/mitchell.html
[2] https://terebess.hu/english/tao/henricks.html
[3] https://terebess.hu/english/tao/wu.html