Re:DHS uses travel as pretext for search of researcher and j...
by nerdponx on Thursday September 28, 2023 @03:15PM
(#37694290)
The Miranda ruling is weirdly narrow to me. Ideally you would be informed of your legal rights in any scenario, just to the particular case of arrest.
Re:DHS uses travel as pretext for search of researcher and j...
by olliej on Thursday September 28, 2023 @03:38PM
(#37694660)
And also courts routinely narrow it even further - things like a person saying "I think I want a lawyer" have been found to not be asking for a lawyer, etc
Re:DHS uses travel as pretext for search of researcher and j...
by singleshot_ on Thursday September 28, 2023 @03:49PM
(#37694821)
You have a lot of rights. Many of them are conditional or depend on the facts of your situation. The fact that such a warning could potentially take hours to recite and be outside of the capability of law enforcement to understand make your proposal challenging.
Miranda works because you can write those limited rights on a card in words small enough for a cop to say.
Lawyers and only lawyers-- is there some kind of workable legislation that could require agents to inform citizens of their rights under the PPA before demanding access to the phone, something like Miranda rights but for interrogations?
It really sucks that this journalist can't get damages essentially because they forgot to do a null check right before the search.