Re:Rust vs Go: A Hands-On Comparison
by pclmulqdq on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @02:10PM
(#37678723)
It sounds like you have a strong personal preference for Rust, which is fine. I'm pretty sure nobody loves Go as much as many people love Rust.
Even 100k LOC is pretty small for a software project, and likely doesn't need more than a few engineers. The advantage of the simplicity of Go shows up when you have to coordinate across >100 people, many of which are kind of mediocre, and you need all of them to ship features. If everyone in the world were a genius who is obsessed with writing clean code, Rust would be a fantastic language to work in at that scale, but they are not.
Re:Rust vs Go: A Hands-On Comparison
by blindseer on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @02:21PM
(#37678901)
For clarification, these are 100k LOC projects where I'm the only software engineer. I've worked on larger projects in C++ with other engineers, and would absolutely continue to prefer Rust as the size of the codebase increases. I guess my point is that Rust scales in a way that few languages do. Go comes close though :)
I counted the number of lines in my work projects, and I have $WORK projects that are 100k lines of code. Maintaining that in Go would seem like a nightmare to me, but in Rust that is so much nicer. My personal projects range from 10k - 35k and in all of those I much prefer the ones where I'm writing and maintaining Rust vs Go when it comes to similar complexity.