Bandwidth is cheap. The bandwidth to give everyone in a mid sized city 100mb internet access costs around 20$/person a month + the cost of the wires. So, if Comcast provides 5mb internet for X$ they can make money providing 100mb for X + 20$. Yet, they want to both charge 3+ times that AND make money on side deals AND keep their local monopoly.
Now, latency is a slightly different issue. I would suggest that it's reasonable to either run an extra line OR host some servers locally to deal with that. But, assuming you have a sane network topology there are vary few cases where latency is actually important. Yet, if Comcast sees an opportunity to profit from the latency game they will do so. They already provide crappy DNS service to slow people down just think what they will do if they think latency is the path to extra profit.
PS: You could replace Comcast with Cox and probably just about any other local cable company and say the same things. But, I just happen to know more about Comcast and they are in the article so I stick with them.
I do not want to be in the position of defending Comcast (who I hate with fiery passion), but that sounds a bit like arguing that the cost of manufacturing an Adobe Photoshop disc is relevant to how much it can or should cost.
How does running an extra line lower your latency? I think you're confusing bandwidth and latency here. Latency would involve replacing your line with better infrastructure (small impact) or changing the route your packets would tend to take to one with fewer hops and shorter distances (big impact).
That's not for consumer broadband access. It's not even for commercial broadband access. It's a specific use, point-to-point network connection. It's important to separate general broadband access from special-purpose network connections for net neutrality purposes.
Paying a company to bring fiber into your area and then leveraging their service over that fiber is very different from consumers dealing with (typically) municipal contractually-enforced monopolies that restrict their access to the internet. I'm a capitalist kind of a guy, but monopolies destroy the dynamics of the free market and have to be kept firmly in check.
>Given that ISPs charge each other for transporting traffic [4] it costs more to broker traffi[...]
I don't think anyone is arguing that there isn't a cost motive for providing tiered pricing. Of course there is.
The issue is that monopolies must either be broken up or they must provide special protections for both consumers and the health of the free market in general. Net neutrality is that protection and it trumps Comcast's cost-based-pricing motives.
I doubt Comcast put in data caps because of interconnect costs. I would love to see what a gig of interconnect data costs them.
In the US we pay about $3/Mbps [4], suggesting a healthy minimum 1/5 profit margin. This happens to be around CMCSA's 1/5 operating margin (suggesting the transit price is lower) [5].
I couldn't find data for internal transit prices, but assuming everyone runs with about a 1/5 margin on transit costs as well (likely too dear) we can take $1.9/Mbps as being a decent relative estimate of internal costs. This is a $0.45/Mbps or 15 percentage point to revenue difference.
[1] http://drpeering.net/AskDrPeering/blog/articles/Peering_vs_T...
[2] http://drpeering.net/white-papers/Internet-Transit-Pricing-H...
[3] http://conferences.sigcomm.org/sigcomm/2011/papers/sigcomm/p...
[4] http://dailyinfographic.com/internet-speeds-around-the-world...
What does the author mean? Comcast certainly doesn't own the entire Internet, so why is it a meaningless distinction?
Source discrimination is bad. The Internet allows applications and services to run “at the edge” of the network and not centrally; this encourages innovation [1].
Path discrimination is more complicated. Many content providers already pay private networks to transport their traffic on faster than the public internet [2]. There is even a market for traders paying tens to hundreds of thousands of dollars for low latency connections [3].
Given that ISPs charge each other for transporting traffic [4] it costs more to broker traffic across others' networks versus its own. It doesn't seem unfair for the ISP to charge less for the latter. This would allow Comcast et al to compete with the Akamais and Level3s that irk them today [5]. Sooner or later they will find it makes more sense to offer the discount for same-network traffic to everyone.
Comcast has made shitty statements about net neutrality before [1]. But it's not okay to vilify anything Comcast says by virtue of it being said by Comcast - that's straight up ad hominem.
[1] http://www.stern.nyu.edu/networks/Economides_Net_Neutrality....
[2] http://techcrunch.com/2010/11/11/level-3-lands-netflix-strea...
[3] http://www.highfrequencytraders.com/article/682/options-it-o...
[4] http://blog.teracomtraining.com/how-isps-connect-to-the-inte...
[5] http://blog.comcast.com/2010/11/comcast-comments-on-level-3....