Re:Google assigns a CVE for libwebp and gives it a 10.0 score
by ninkendo on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @05:36PM
(#37666111)
We know that the webp project does use unchecked access. We know this is intentional because they go through a lot of effort to do up front bounds checking rather than at every access. We also know that companies like Dropbox, when implementing their own Huffman table implementation, demonstrated an 11% speed up when disabling bounds checks: https://dropbox.tech/infrastructure/lossless-compression-wit...
It is not a stretch whatsoever to assume that a direct rewrite of the webp library into rust would have uncovered the same perf findings that Dropbox did, and decided that the pattern of “up front bounds checks, disabled bounds checks at element access” is a reasonable perf enhancement, especially for a Huffman table, where you’re continually accessing the compression table over and over when expanding it.
It is not a stretch whatsoever to assume that a direct rewrite of the webp library into rust would have uncovered the same perf findings that Dropbox did, and decided that the pattern of “up front bounds checks, disabled bounds checks at element access” is a reasonable perf enhancement, especially for a Huffman table, where you’re continually accessing the compression table over and over when expanding it.