And depending on the source you look at, Truck Driver isn't even in the top 25 for men (it's mostly construction, HVAC, Pipe fitting, and related jobs).
And in fact one source I looked at said that software engineering employs more men than truck driving (but that source was dubious).
https://www.census.gov/library/stories/2019/06/america-keeps...
> Automated trucking means possibly lower prices, and AI entertainment does to.
We currently have inflation driven across a wide swathe of goods, driven primarily by corporate greed, and streaming services jacking up prices while putting out endless reboot and IP farm garbage. I’m not sure what would ever lead you to this conclusion.
For lowering prices vs. eating the profits, I think a bit of both happens in most industries. There are plenty of examples where better tech constantly leads to lower prices - basically most PC hardware like SSDs today. IMO these kinds of things never get media attention but yeah prices do get lower in many areas. The dynamics of whether they extract profits or pass on savings are complex and vary over time depending on competition etc. but over the long term its hard to argue that some industry will get more efficient but no one else will start competing with the same tech to bring prices down. For self driving cars we have 2-3 players in the field too which is a good sign.
Overall this argument has been rehashed for different technologies many times. Horse drivers vs. cars, scribes vs. typewriters blah blah. Its difficult to argue we would have been better off today by protecting jobs over letting the technology help everyone eventually. Personally i think this transition will be rough though, a lot of people including programmers are going to lose their jobs and we might have years of pain ahead before things stabilize. But in the long term yeah its better than just hiding AI in a box and pretending like nothing happened.
My problem is that people are increasingly blaming technology for the failures of the government. Self driving trucks SHOULD make things cheaper. Having a robot do things that people used to do SHOULD help us all in the long run the same way washing machines do.
But when it doesn't, people have such low expectations of the government that they don't even consider that option. Like are we supposed to just stop all scientific and technological progress that could endanger jobs now, just freeze society in the state its at now?
The way I see it we need both levers, science and government to make progress. Lately the sentiment is we should burn down the half that works because the other half doesn't work. I think that's the wrong approach.
[1] https://ised-isde.canada.ca/site/competition-bureau-canada/e...
I am shocked how little sympathy people have for e,g, teachers, who impact their kids every day, and have been consistently crapped on for decades on this continent. General public's overall sympathy to unions and/or truckers is limited.
Unfortunately, most people's attitude is "I don't have that, so they shouldn't either!" or "My life is hard, theirs should be too!!!". It would be more productive and compassionate to say "I don't have what they're asking for either, maybe I should do something about that and we'll all get better", but sadly that's not how it tends to work :-<
As parent, you basically have to find tutors, enroll kids into AoPS/Russian Math, etc… I, for one, stopped understanding what is it that these teachers actually do?
Teachers have definitely been "crapped on" for a long time, but they fervently argue for the system from which the crap flows.
When her job became more overhead than actually teaching, that's when she called it quits. Now she volunteers most of the day at school trying to help the teachers in any way she can to make their jobs easier.
https://katv.com/news/nation-world/chicago-teachers-union-le...
if the windows of the truck are tinted and you can't tell whether or not an AI is driving and if the script isn't signed with an author's signature and you can't tell who wrote it then who how will you even know to be upset or not?
Radical idea here: How about some places accept autonomous trucks, and some places accept human-operated ones, and then customers can choose which places they frequent? If they truly would side with truck drivers, they should go to stores that only used human-operated trucks without the need for legislation, right?
A Verge article [0] has some discussion on this with regard to a motorcyclist that follows this pattern, and FortNine also covers this in a characteristically well-made video [1].
There's also the problem of autonomous (electric) cars being too quiet when they first begin moving, but that's easy to solve.
So I'm not entirely sure about their safety being "proven", but that's largely because the problem domain is enormous and the data somewhat open to interpretation. Overall "proved" seems too certain a word as of now, without narrowly defining the scope.
[0] https://www.theverge.com/2022/7/27/23280461/tesla-autopilot-...
Not to discount the obvious potential safety issues, just noting that Tesla is taking a very different approach that is currently pretty far from being able to complete trips consistently, let alone be measured up against human drivers.
Certainly there are good reasons why SFFD is not keen on Waymo and Cruise.
Self-driving (and AI in general) has a tendency to go catastrophically wrong for impossible to determine reasons (imagine if each hallucination was a potential traffic accident), in a way that is hard to predict and is essentially open ended in terms of consequence. Humans do very stupid things much much less often than fairly stupid things - no such correlation is offered by AI.
I don't think that's true. I live in SF and am not aware of a single catastrophe owing to self-driving cars, let alone enough such catastrophes to form a statistical sample from which we could reliably infer tendencies.
It could be slightly lower but its still pretty high. This poll says 74% of likely voters support a prohibition on AI replacing humans for writing TV shows compared to 67% support for the strike overall.
It is a lot lower than the 87% support for "appropriate compensation" for reruns and streaming, but I think that is a much less contentious question than the AI writing prohibition one. By definition practically everyone agrees that they deserve "appropriate" compensation, the debate is over what is appropriate.
https://www.dataforprogress.org/blog/2023/8/17/a-majority-of...
We would obviously need to collect lots of data with safety drivers in place to determine how often they are necessary and how many accidents (both lethal and non-lethal) the trucks get into to determine if they really are dangerous, but this is a totally reasonable take from the head of the CFL.
> "We will continue to fight to make sure that robots do not replace human drivers and that technology is not used to destroy good jobs.”
Using union power to protect jobs just for the sake of protecting them is the thing that labor unions do that most people don't support. See the recent writer's strike for a good example -- many supported their desire for better wages and working conditions, but feelings were much more mixed on support for allowing AI to replace writers.