Re:It's time to let go, Apache Software Foundation
by saurik on Monday September 25, 2023 @12:21PM
(#37646387)
I believe a key issue is that the license of LibreOffice is copyleft (I believe some mixture of LGPL and MPL) and so the Apache Foundation--which specifically focuses on code that is not copyleft (a focus I personally disagree with, but is at least consistent)--feels something is lost to the world if they truly give up on the one permissively-licensed open source office suite.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:It's time to let go, Apache Software Foundation
by bogwog on Monday September 25, 2023 @12:46PM
(#37646795)
That's a good point I haven't seen brought up before when this topic comes up. That really does make a lot of sense explaining why Open Office still exists, but not why Apache is not being transparent about the situation.
The pointless commits combined with the lack of transparency feel a bit nefarious. I wonder if it's more about personal drama between the projects than anything else?
Re:It's time to let go, Apache Software Foundation
by purpleidea on Monday September 25, 2023 @01:00PM
(#37647055)
You're completely right! The issue is, this mandate is being made by corporate donors and influencers which is why ASF should be a 501(c)(6) not a 501(c)(3) that it is. It's probably breaking the law, but at least unethical.
Re:It's time to let go, Apache Software Foundation
by phkahler on Monday September 25, 2023 @01:43PM
(#37647740)
>> I believe a key issue is that the license of LibreOffice is copyleft (I believe some mixture of LGPL and MPL) and so the Apache Foundation--which specifically focuses on code that is not copyleft (a focus I personally disagree with, but is at least consistent)--feels something is lost to the world if they truly give up on the one permissively-licensed open source office suite.
And here I thought they were just against OpenOffice, this interpretation pits them against Free Software more generally. I'm gonna run with that for a while and see how it fits.
Re:It's time to let go, Apache Software Foundation
by yencabulator on Monday September 25, 2023 @06:36PM
(#37651675)
Then again, the Apache2-licensed OpenOffice is not lost to the world even if it sits in attic.apache.org. If and when someone wants to maintain it, it can be resurrected.