News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Time Doesn’t Belong to Physics by spookthesunset on Monday September 25, 2023 @10:48AM (#37644736)
How do you believe the results you are getting? What makes such a belief justified?

What is the nature of consciousness?

What are things beautiful? What makes something ascetically pleasing.

Why any of this exists at all?

What is the purpose of this existence?

Is something ethical? Science can provide answer about consequences of an action but cannot determine if said action is moral or ethical.

… science is not a book of facts. It is merely a process for testing a hypothesis. It is not a replacement for philosophy, it is underpinned by philosophy.

Re:Time Doesn’t Belong to Physics by username332211 on Monday September 25, 2023 @11:31AM (#37645483)
Ethics in particular is rather interesting. I think it's the field where the decline of philosophy is most apparent.

Ethics is supposed to answer real-life questions, like "How do I live a moral life?".

Yet philosophical movements like stoicism, that actually tired to answer such questions are long gone. When you read on the actual writings of contemporary philosophers you'd see impossible moral standards - "If it takes 5 dollars to save a starving African child, a night out with friends is the equivalent to abandoning a bus of drowning children to their deaths"[1]

It's impossible to live by such philosophy, except for those that think of themselves as some sort of a creature of pure evil who cares nothing of right and wrong.

Because philosophy is useless for guidance to life, right and wrong are now decided by the encyclical, the fatwa and the resolutions at the party congress, depending on your religion.

[1] https://daily-philosophy.com/peter-singers-drowning-child/

Re:Time Doesn’t Belong to Physics by whatshisface on Monday September 25, 2023 @11:34AM (#37645528)
Maybe living impassively at the top of a rich world hegemony while children are starving is wrong but we are too used to it to notice.
Re:Time Doesn’t Belong to Physics by username332211 on Monday September 25, 2023 @12:20PM (#37646375)
Ohh, it's not just the rich world that's guilty. Do you think there are no bars in Haiti? Do you think they don't waste stuff on "personal luxuries" in Bangladesh? Do you think they don't waste their time and resources on shopping malls in Ethiopia? They waste resources that could have gone to the malnourished children of their own country!

Monsters, the lot of them, just as bad as the rich-worlders. Ethics demands we all live joyless lives of endless toil until every child is fed.

Re:Time Doesn’t Belong to Physics by whatshisface on Monday September 25, 2023 @12:25PM (#37646431)
Rich people living in third world countries would definitely be included in that especially because rather than some vague "foreign policy" being the causal link for culpability they can often be the corrupt individuals creating the problem themselves. Saying "people who live in penthouses next to Indian slums might be living their life wrong too" is not exactly an expression of disagreement.
Re:Time Doesn’t Belong to Physics by username332211 on Monday September 25, 2023 @12:44PM (#37646756)
Perhaps I was unclear. I wasn't talking about rich people. Poor people need to enjoy life just as much as rich people, if not more. Who spends more time at bars, the rich or the poor?

Do you think an Ethiopian community is immoral because it puts effort into having enjoyable festivals, dignified funerals and large weddings? Think of all the effort that could have gone to the starving children!

Here's a more practical question for you. There's a homeless guy who hangs around my place. He's definitely not malnourished, in fact he's somewhat fat. If I give him a dollar, should he return it to me with instructions to give it to African children instead?

Re:Time Doesn’t Belong to Physics by whatshisface on Monday September 25, 2023 @01:06PM (#37647172)
Having a party when there are people starving outside may actually be immoral, yes, even in Ethiopia. I'm not basing my argument on "Americans bad" so much as admitting there could be something to this whole "how are you so able to ignore the extreme suffering of others?" question... Maybe we would be better if none of us could do that.
Re:Time Doesn’t Belong to Physics by esafak on Monday September 25, 2023 @12:49PM (#37646859)
> "It takes 5 dollars to save a starving African child, a night out with friends is the equivalent to abandoning a bus of drowning children to their deaths".

These philosophical thought experiments are too simplistic to offer any guidance. Five dollars does not save any starving child, for he will need food for the rest of his childhood. And they also neglect the social aspect of the problem. What if this whole neighborhood or country is poor? It is more sensible to attack this problem using the tools of developmental economics; how can we alleviate the problem for everyone over time?

Re:Time Doesn’t Belong to Physics by username332211 on Monday September 25, 2023 @01:19PM (#37647384)
I completely agree. Funnily enough, the first published work of economics Glasgow professor of moral philosophy wrote a book about systemic issues. Before that, philosophers from Aristotle to Hume dealt with matters like credit and currency as ethical issues.

The only think I'd have to add is I don't think the thought experiment is merely "too simplistic". It's an evil sophistry designed to make people believe ethical conduct is unattainable.

Re:Time Doesn’t Belong to Physics by lisper on Monday September 25, 2023 @11:22AM (#37645323)
Those are all very good questions, and I can't do them justice in an HN comment. But here's a first cut:

> How do you believe the results you are getting? What makes such a belief justified?

Read David Deutsch "The Fabric of Reality" chapter 7.

> What is the nature of consciousness?

Read Daniel Dennett, "Consciousness Explained".

> What are things beautiful? What makes something ascetically pleasing.

Read Richard Dawkins, "The Selfish Gene" (and, if you want to get deep into these weeds, "The Extended Phenotype").

> Why any of this exists at all?

What makes you think that any of this does exist at all?

> What is the purpose of this existence?

What makes you think that this existence has a purpose?

> Is something ethical? Science can provide answer about consequences of an action but cannot determine if said action is moral or ethical.

Read "The Evolution of Cooperation" by Robert Axelrod. (The Selfish Gene addresses this as well.)

> science is not a book of facts.

That's true.

> It is merely a process for testing a hypothesis.

No, it's not "merely" that. It is a process for producing good explanations that account for observations. That turns out to be tremendously powerful.

> It is not a replacement for philosophy, it is underpinned by philosophy.

No, it isn't. The existence of philosophy (and philosophers!) can be explained by science.

Re:Time Doesn’t Belong to Physics by zquzra on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @12:17AM (#37654277)
Daniel Dennett is a philosopher.
Re:Time Doesn’t Belong to Physics by lisper on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @02:13AM (#37655106)
He's also a scientist.
Re:Time Doesn’t Belong to Physics by dventimi on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @03:45AM (#37655844)
What distinguishes a scientist from a philosopher?
Re:Time Doesn’t Belong to Physics by lisper on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @11:45AM (#37661066)
A scientist follows the scientific method, i.e. they advance testable hypotheses and compare their predictions with the data. A philosopher writes deep-sounding but ultimately meaningless drivel like this:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tractatus_Logico-Philosophicus

Re:Time Doesn’t Belong to Physics by dventimi on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @01:42PM (#37662981)
Which comically was criticized by its own author here:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philosophical_Investigations

It's not lost on me that Tractatus was warmly received by philosophers, but Investigations got a frostier reception from the same group. I especially enjoyed Russell's snippy quote. Ol Ludwig struck a nerve, did he, Bert?

Re:Time Doesn’t Belong to Physics by dventimi on Monday September 25, 2023 @02:52PM (#37648742)
Few scientists try to answer these questions for me. I expect philosophers to have as much humility.
Re:Time Doesn’t Belong to Physics by analog31 on Monday September 25, 2023 @11:11PM (#37653855)
And what are the answers from philosophy? Last I looked, all that philosophy could offer to questions like that was an enumeration of multiple conflicting answers.