Re:Text editing on mobile isn’t ok
by scottjenson on Sunday September 24, 2023 @08:10PM
(#37638364)
I'm the author of the paper. That first one though you called out is VERY interesting (the others seem quite close to what is already done today)
We tried pause-to-select and it user tested very poorly as users were thrown into selection far too easily. It was very irritating. However, I can't really criticize it until I've tried it. I'll upgrade my iPad and check it out. Thanks.
* Immediately start dragging. When you pause it immediately enters text selection. If you move slowly you get the loupe otherwise it starts jumping word by word in the text
* When you release you get the popup options to do something with your text
* Holding the end of the selection and moving slowly gives you fine control over the cursor.
* When editing this comment, it doesn’t immediately jump to selection but gives you cursor control right away after long press with the magnified loupe. Move fast enough and the magnifier disappears. This is different behavior from long pressing the space bar.
* Double tap and drag gives you the selection behavior.
* Double tap and no drag selects the word.
Actual coding on a touchscreen is still impossible even with the articles improvements. I’d like to see more work on that. I wonder if speaking to our devices inaudibly could be the long term way forward.