If you need it, then you need it, but having the certification is a mildly bad sign in my opinion.
I’m not the only one with this opinion. For instance, the Microsoft Windows team seems to agree:
https://techcommunity.microsoft.com/t5/microsoft-security-ba...
Thanks for the link.
However, the whole FIPS and USG compliance in general mindset is not that; the goal instead is "be aware of ways in which your system is known to not be secure". The idea that a known flaw is better than an less-known fix is infuriating to devs, but from a business standpoint it makes some sense.
I’ve only seen them force changes were ones that weaken or remove defenses against known attacks.
I’ve never seen them require additional standard defenses, or identity and propose fixes against attacks that were not already considered and addressed by the existing system.
FIPS support continues to be the top customer ask by a wide margin. Unfortunately the timing here is not kind for a new distro with no previous FIPS offering. New FIPS 140-2 certifications are no longer available, and new FIPS 140-3 certifications have to make it through a lengthy queue as the entire industry switches over.
If this were something the dev team could just power through, I assure you it would have happened by now. I apologize for giving the impression that it’s not important. It is, but that doesn’t help the timeline in this case.
Here's your reminder that even if FIPS itself isn't evil, it moves in evil circles with evil people. [2]
[1] https://twitter.com/matthew_d_green/status/41279364233232384...
[2] https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1433451378391883782.html
Just to save anybody the trouble who needs FIPS approved encryption for host OSes that you use at work for various compliance programs. This makes Bottlerocket a non-starter for us. A very active issue has been open for over 2 years on this and the dev teams don't seem to be convinced that this is important. We even communicated with the dev team through our dedicated AWS reps and they have no interest in adding this.
Here is the open 2+ year thread on this: https://github.com/bottlerocket-os/bottlerocket/issues/1667