Re:She got famous on YouTube. Now it helps fund her research...
by ben_w on Saturday September 23, 2023 @03:53PM
(#37626835)
I like her sense of humour. I respect her as a physicist. I respect her as a general science news reporter.
These are however very different things, and "science reporter" is something where my expectations in general — not just her, everyone doing this — is that at best and when trying sincerely and with skill, they will still misunderstand and misrepresent as per a game of telephone.
This means I do still listen to what she has to say "out of her lane", but I don't rank it as highly as her videos in her own domain of expertise, instead treating them more like a Tom Scott video. (Tom, if you're reading this, that's still a decent standard).
These are however very different things, and "science reporter" is something where my expectations in general — not just her, everyone doing this — is that at best and when trying sincerely and with skill, they will still misunderstand and misrepresent as per a game of telephone.
This means I do still listen to what she has to say "out of her lane", but I don't rank it as highly as her videos in her own domain of expertise, instead treating them more like a Tom Scott video. (Tom, if you're reading this, that's still a decent standard).
I do appreciate that she explained how she does the research for these: https://youtu.be/nD6hS8WV3ic?si=raJ3UySkXZOgZfIn