Re:Fossil versus Git
by IshKebab on Saturday September 23, 2023 @08:45AM
(#37622765)
People only think large blobs don't belong in VCS because they don't work well with Git.
As soon as a VCS comes along that actually handles that properly people will say "of course, it was obvious that it should have been like this all along!".
Git LFS is a proof of concept, not a real solution.
Unfortunately none of the new Git alternatives I've seen (Jujitsu, Pijul etc) are tackling the real pain points of Git:
* Submodule support is incomplete, buggy and unintuitive
* No way to store large files that actually integrates properly with Git.
* Poor support for very large monorepos where you only want to clone part of it.
In a way, Git is bad at everything that centralised VCS systems are good at, which isn't surprising given that it's decentralised. The problem is that most people actually use it as a centralised VCS and want those features.
As soon as a VCS comes along that actually handles that properly people will say "of course, it was obvious that it should have been like this all along!".
Git LFS is a proof of concept, not a real solution.
Unfortunately none of the new Git alternatives I've seen (Jujitsu, Pijul etc) are tackling the real pain points of Git:
* Submodule support is incomplete, buggy and unintuitive
* No way to store large files that actually integrates properly with Git.
* Poor support for very large monorepos where you only want to clone part of it.
In a way, Git is bad at everything that centralised VCS systems are good at, which isn't surprising given that it's decentralised. The problem is that most people actually use it as a centralised VCS and want those features.