Re:500MW from half a gram of hydrogen: The hunt for fusion p...
by tgflynn on Tuesday March 27, 2012 @10:45AM
(#3761757)
Just to be clear, now that I have a better understanding of your proposal, I didn't mean that a device in which the majority of the energy comes from fusion isn't feasible, just not typical.
Quantitatively I don't know how large you can make the fusion/fission energy ratio but there will always be some fission with the radioactive decay product problems inherent to that.
Re:500MW from half a gram of hydrogen: The hunt for fusion p...
by tocomment on Tuesday March 27, 2012 @11:37AM
(#3762064)
So maybe it would work? You just need a way to handle the radioactive waste, and a way to engineer on a very large scale.
Re:500MW from half a gram of hydrogen: The hunt for fusion p...
by tocomment on Tuesday March 27, 2012 @10:07AM
(#3761537)
I don't seem to be allowed to reply to the comment below:
> How does your design address that ? Are you saying the fusion reactions would be triggered by the mechanical compression of the pistons in the cylinder ?
I'm saying fusion reactions are triggered by the detonation of a hydrogen bomb (fission triggers fusion inside the bomb).
Re:500MW from half a gram of hydrogen: The hunt for fusion p...
by tgflynn on Tuesday March 27, 2012 @10:17AM
(#3761593)
OK, so then what you're proposing isn't a pure fusion reactor but a hybrid fusion-fission reactor. That's probably going to combine many of the disadvantages of fusion and fission. You get both the highly radioactive and long-life decay products of fission, still need relatively rare fissile fuel and you get the containment problems of fusion.
Moreover if you need a fission explosion trigger you need a critical mass of fissile material for each detonation so there's a limit to how far you can scale down the process.
I think it's highly unlikely this could be practical.
Re:500MW from half a gram of hydrogen: The hunt for fusion p...
by tgflynn on Tuesday March 27, 2012 @10:04AM
(#3761527)
I mainly suggest my design because it seems so difficult to trigger fusion without fission using current technology.
How does your design address that ? Are you saying the fusion reactions would be triggered by the mechanical compression of the pistons in the cylinder ?
If this is true, then that puts a kink in my design. I assumed the vast majority of energy output was from fusion. (why else would they build them?)
I mainly suggest my design because it seems so difficult to trigger fusion without fission using current technology.