News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I'm fed up with it, so I'm writing a browser by jwells89 on Friday September 22, 2023 @09:12AM (#37611585)
I think a lot of distaste towards GPL comes from devs with corporate day jobs who feel frustrated that anything GPL licensed is functionally off-limits at work because there’s no way legal would approve of using it, and certainly would not approve of open sourcing whatever project is built with the GPL thing. I can see where such an individual might think to themselves, “I don’t want to put other devs in my position in the same pickle, so I’m licensing my thing as MIT/BSD”.
Re:I'm fed up with it, so I'm writing a browser by waprin on Friday September 22, 2023 @12:51PM (#37614378)
This hints at it but misses what I consider the more important underlying dynamic.

“Open source” was initially popularized by the copyleft ideological people like Stallman. They had ideas and opinions about software freedoms and open source was a key component of those ideas.

Since then many companies have discovered there’s business and commercial reasons to open source code. I was at the TGIF when Jeff Dean talked about open sourcing Tensorflow. Previously, they thought novel dev infra tools were high value IP so released some white papers but no code. Then they found it embarrassing to launch “Google Cloud Bigtable, implementing the industry standard HBase API”. HBase was based on the Bigtable paper but now Google had to make compromises because they didn’t define the standard API because they didn’t open source it. There’s other business reasons to open source such as being able to hire new employees already familiar with your tools and using open source to nudge people towards your paid cloud offerings, which is part of the business case for open sourcing Kubernetes. Google open sourced Tensorflow and Kubernetes purely for business reasons, not due to any interest in ideology.

The reason this is relevant is because ideological open source motivations and commercial open source motivations are very different. But since the end result looks similar, people constantly conflate the two. I’d say the majority of modern open source is really about commercial motivations but people more often discuss the topic as if the motivation was ideological or based on goodwill.

Once you realize the underlying motivations it’s obvious that if you’re trying to define an industry standard, you want as widespread adoption as possible and copyleft licenses undermine that.

Even this breakdown of motivations oversimplifies things but I still think it’s worth calling out because I repeatedly see people muddle their understanding based on missing this key distinction. And it’s understandable because it’s counter intuitive that you give stuff away for free in order to make lots of money.

But once you realize that many open source projects are open source primarily so that the creators can make lots of money, a lot of mysteries aren’t so mysterious anymore.

Re:I'm fed up with it, so I'm writing a browser by downWidOutaFite on Friday September 22, 2023 @01:57PM (#37615349)
Right, corporate lawyers are ideological activists trying to kill GPL. But the campaign to denigrate the ideological activists on the other side is much more successful.
Re:I'm fed up with it, so I'm writing a browser by freedomben on Friday September 22, 2023 @03:26PM (#37616549)
> Right, corporate lawyers are ideological activists trying to kill GPL.

This is a pretty cynical "assume the worst" outlook, and it badly violates Occam's Razor. I think a much more likely reason that corporate lawyers disapprove of the GPL is that one of their main jobs (in some cases their entire job) is to protect the company's IP, and the GPL is a huge threat to IP. Any lawyer who didn't advise avoiding the GPL would be negligent. I personally love the GPL and encourage its use whenever possible, but I avoid it in decisions for my employers and customers because of the risks. I think generally speaking the risks are not nearly as serious as most people I think, but they do exist (otherwise the copyleft philosophy of the GPL would be pointless!)

Re:I'm fed up with it, so I'm writing a browser by downWidOutaFite on Friday September 22, 2023 @11:35PM (#37620394)
I've seen too many cases, recent example comes to mind is apple switching from bash to zsh, that are done not for technical or even business reason but ideological.
Re:I'm fed up with it, so I'm writing a browser by freedomben on Friday September 22, 2023 @03:30PM (#37616598)
Absolutely. I'm personally a big fan of the GPL but I've felt that way before as well. When there's a great library that I want to use but it's GPL and the program I'm writing is IP, the request/proposal is dead on arrival. From that dev's perspective there's not much difference between an extant but GPLed library and a non-existent library.

That said, I do wish people would be a little more nuanced about it. IMHO (generally speaking) make libraries permissive, make applications GPL