2) I don't get why people keep lecturing a guy who built AOSP products with wildly wrong understandings of Android's update structure
Browser, Mail, and Messages are all baked into AOSP just like iOS... they're just so awful they mostly stopped getting updated: https://android.googlesource.com/platform/packages/apps/
You're instead referring to Google Play Services alternatives, which get updated but also don't represent the headline features that get announced with new Android releases.
> Most users would not see difference between major releases anyway
Absurd take when Google spends literal millions marketing the new features native to Android releases (not app releases, Android releases)
And in less than a year the binary blobs running half the phone in your pocket will no longer get updated, so it elevates from being a feature issue to being a security issue.
The Galaxy S20 FE doesn't run AOSP though. It has Chrome, GMail and Messages from Google and all of them get updated via the Play Store.
... sound about right chief?
2) System updates do not mean the same on Android and iOS. On Android, all the apps are going to be updated still. Browser, mail, chat, maps are not hostages to system update. Conversely, security-only updates on Android are perfectly fine. Most users would not see difference between major releases anyway.