News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stop sending .DOC files as mail attachments There is a be... by DanBC on Tuesday March 27, 2012 @07:30AM (#3760963)
In theory there are some features in word processing packages for security (either password to open or password to edit) and for collaborative working (edits are marked) that you don't get with HTML. In practice, those security features are often broken.

HTML and CSS would be an excellent solution, and in tune with the original idea (device-agnostic) of HTML. You don't know what software, or OS, or machine the receiver is viewing your document; you don't even know if they're using a screen.

I get a bit frustrated when websites do weird[1] things like force a display size (too narrow for most real monitors and too wide for most portable monitors, thus annoying both markets.) Maybe if HTML had taken off for print documents people would spend less time tinkering with the fonts and the 8px margins and more time on the content?

[1] You all know the stupid website decisions I mean.

Re:Stop sending .DOC files as mail attachments There is a be... by oddthink on Tuesday March 27, 2012 @08:30AM (#3761111)
Unfortunately, HTML isn't a rich enough container. If you try to add a diagram to HTML, suddenly you need two files. The "webarchive" file formats get around this, but they're not standard.

It seems to me that we need something like PDF, but that isn't so hung up on the idea of formatting physical pages. If I'm reading on a phone, I want it to reflow.

Re:Stop sending .DOC files as mail attachments There is a be... by mbenkard on Tuesday March 27, 2012 @09:31AM (#3761361)
If you try to add a diagram to HTML, suddenly you need two files.

That's not strictly true. You can embed inline object data in object tags (http://www.w3.org/TR/html40/struct/objects.html#h-13.3) using the data: URI scheme (http://www.faqs.org/rfcs/rfc2397.html). Whether that is good enough, I don't know. The data needing to be physically inserted at each point of use certainly isn't great for space usage and performance.

But then, in the context of email, why not just use MIME?

Re:Stop sending .DOC files as mail attachments There is a be... by acdha on Tuesday March 27, 2012 @09:12AM (#3761260)
HTML isn't a container at all but what you're describing is basically ePub3 - HTML and resources inside a container, designed for reflow and other advanced scenarios which clash with PDF's basic philosophy.
Re:Stop sending .DOC files as mail attachments There is a be... by oddthink on Tuesday March 27, 2012 @09:43AM (#3761424)
That's true; ePub is certainly trying to do the right thing here. I haven't used it much myself, so I don't know how well it works. For my own uses, I'd like to get decent equations and LaTeX-like special characters (e.g. \nabla), but I can live with embedded PNG or GIF.

(Not that that really alters the basic point, which was that HTML, by itself, isn't enough. The object tag might be a good enough solution, I don't know.)

Re:Stop sending .DOC files as mail attachments There is a be... by monsterix on Tuesday March 27, 2012 @08:40AM (#3761146)
I bet you're wrong. There is nothing more than just a container, a space and memory hog, that word processors and Adobe suites provide. I believe that HTML is far more powerful than currently tapped.
Re:Stop sending .DOC files as mail attachments There is a be... by freehunter on Tuesday March 27, 2012 @09:17AM (#3761287)
There is nothing more than just a container, a space and memory hog, that word processors and Adobe suites provide.

Which is exactly what OP was complaining about. HTML documents need multiple files to work correctly. .DOC and .PDF provide this. There is no standard for HTML containters.

I believe that HTML is far more powerful than currently tapped.

Key term for this chapter is "than currently tapped". The problem is, .DOC and .PDF solve all the problems HTML documents have.

The take-home assignment is to make an HTML container that can be read and edited in software that everyone has, then convince the world (and hiring managers) that everyone should stop using Word even though it works perfectly fine. Extra credit if you make it as rich and feature filled as Word without making it more bloated than Word.

Re:Stop sending .DOC files as mail attachments There is a be... by monsterix on Tuesday March 27, 2012 @04:33PM (#3763461)
That's a tough bet, but not undo-able. Looking at capabilities extended by HTML5, and the containers that the browsers already are, I don't feel (though I could be wrong) that day is too far.

Yep, someone has to build a standard for HTML containers to contain documentary elements like Word/PDF have done so far.