News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Linux gives up on 6-year LTS kernels, says they’re too mu... by kelnos on Thursday September 21, 2023 @03:30PM (#37602903)
Yup, exactly. I last worked in this field in 2009, and BOM cost (tempered with component availability) was king. This was also a time when hardware was much less capable, so they usually ran something like vxWorks (or, ::shudder::, uClinux). Building the cheapest product that could get to market fastest (so as to beat competitors to the latest WiFi draft standard) was all that mattered.

Your Raspberry Pi example is IMO even more illustrative than you let on. I'll reiterate that even that platform is not open and doesn't have a full set of mainlined drivers, after a decade of incredibly active development, by a team that is much more dedicated to openness than most other device manufacturers. Granted, they picked a base (ugh, Broadcom) that is among the worst when it comes to documentation and open source, but I think that also proves a point: device manufacturers don't have a ton of choice, and need to strike a balance between openness and practical considerations. The Raspberry Pi folks had price and capability targets to go with their openness needs, and they couldn't always get everything they wanted.

There are no comments on this comment yet.