Re:Linux gives up on 6-year LTS kernels, says they’re too mu...
by kelnos on Thursday September 21, 2023 @02:54PM
(#37602268)
Microsoft maintains their kernels/OSes for that long because people are willing to pay for that support.
It's pretty disrespectful to call Linux's process a "bad joke" when these developers mostly aren't getting paid to maintain major versions for any length of time that you'd consider more reasonable.
Meanwhile, if you do want longer-term support for a specific kernel+OS combo, IBM/Red Hat (among others) will be happy to sell it to you. You may think it's inefficient for each enterprise distro to have their own internal kernel fork that they maintain (rather than all contributing to a centralized LTS kernel), but that's the choice they've all seemingly collectively made. I guess they feel that if they're on the hook to support it, they want full and final say of what goes into it.
Also consider that Windows doesn't sell a kernel: they sell a full OS. In the Windows world, you don't mix and match kernel versions with the rest of the system. You get what Microsoft has tested and released together. With Linux, I can start with today's Debian stable and run it for years, but continue updating to a new major kernel version (self-building it if I want or need) every two months. The development and support cycle for an OS is very different than that of a kernel. You just can't compare the two directly. If you want to, compare Windows with RHEL.
Also-also consider that Windows and Linux are used in very different contexts. Microsoft's customers may largely care about different things than (e.g.) Red Hat's customers.
It's pretty disrespectful to call Linux's process a "bad joke" when these developers mostly aren't getting paid to maintain major versions for any length of time that you'd consider more reasonable.
Meanwhile, if you do want longer-term support for a specific kernel+OS combo, IBM/Red Hat (among others) will be happy to sell it to you. You may think it's inefficient for each enterprise distro to have their own internal kernel fork that they maintain (rather than all contributing to a centralized LTS kernel), but that's the choice they've all seemingly collectively made. I guess they feel that if they're on the hook to support it, they want full and final say of what goes into it.
Also consider that Windows doesn't sell a kernel: they sell a full OS. In the Windows world, you don't mix and match kernel versions with the rest of the system. You get what Microsoft has tested and released together. With Linux, I can start with today's Debian stable and run it for years, but continue updating to a new major kernel version (self-building it if I want or need) every two months. The development and support cycle for an OS is very different than that of a kernel. You just can't compare the two directly. If you want to, compare Windows with RHEL.
Also-also consider that Windows and Linux are used in very different contexts. Microsoft's customers may largely care about different things than (e.g.) Red Hat's customers.