News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California orders bottled water firm to stop drawing from... by darkwizard42 on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @07:06PM (#37591255)
Water rights are a super complicated and politically challenging issue to navigate. I don't know how it gets solved because so many laws and rules have been passed to protect water rights.

What would happen if a central authority (like say the regulators here) ignored the claim of the bottling company and then also defied the courts to protect some greater good? Is the only remedy for lawmakers to pass laws explicitly disallowing them from using the water?

Generally feels like the right legislation will take forever to get crafted and then will never catch up and if it gets through, it will get (intentionally) jammed up in courts...

Re:California orders bottled water firm to stop drawing from... by Arrath on Wednesday September 20, 2023 @11:23PM (#37592867)
The problem is so deeply seated with agreements, allotments, and obligations going back to homesteading acts and treaties with Native American nations that I fear the system is truly unfixable and needs a ground-up rebuild.

As with any genuine reform efforts, that too would take forever to work its way through legislature and also get blocked up in the courts for god knows how long. What can be done?