Not being in the walled garden provides a lot of freedom and flexibility to setup contingencies.
If we're moving into the realm of the ultra paranoid, high security over convenience focused user - sure. In fact I dare say such a user might prefer a Linux phone with physical keyboard, or no phone at all. But if we're talking average iPhone or Android users here, I can't imagine the scenario would change much at gunpoint.
This is HN though...surely there are a lot of people who care about security and have experience using custom roms.
> you'd likely require root to override the core system and password auth I'd imagine
Honestly, even a simple solution would be putting on something like Prey, which is free and easy to use, and using a third party applocker tool. Those two things don't need a custom rom or any other customization.