Re:64-Bit Bank Balances ‘Ought to Be Enough for Anybody’?
by lxgr on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @03:31PM
(#37575161)
> Well, how much money can you save by efficient rounding?
You and me? Probably a few cents.
A bank or a large corporation selling things billed in sub-cent amounts? Single-digit percentages of their gross revenue, i.e. many millions.
Just as a very simple example: I'm your merchant acquirer/bank, and I'm charging you a fee of 1.9 cents per transaction. You're my customer and make a billion transactions per year.
Option 1: 1000000000 * 0.019 = 19000, you owe me $19000000.
Option 2: There are no fractional cents, so let's just round up each individual billing event. 1000000000 * 0.02 = 20000000, you owe me $20000000. Cool, a free extra million for the company!
This is why these things are precisely regulated when it comes to sales tax/VAT, for example.
> There's a thing called "Kaufmännisches Runden", which is kind of cheating as well.
Always depends on which side you're on. If you're getting a refund, it can work in your favor! Importantly, it's a precisely defined rule so that it's not possible to cheat in the implementation.
You and me? Probably a few cents.
A bank or a large corporation selling things billed in sub-cent amounts? Single-digit percentages of their gross revenue, i.e. many millions.
Just as a very simple example: I'm your merchant acquirer/bank, and I'm charging you a fee of 1.9 cents per transaction. You're my customer and make a billion transactions per year.
Option 1: 1000000000 * 0.019 = 19000, you owe me $19000000.
Option 2: There are no fractional cents, so let's just round up each individual billing event. 1000000000 * 0.02 = 20000000, you owe me $20000000. Cool, a free extra million for the company!
This is why these things are precisely regulated when it comes to sales tax/VAT, for example.
> There's a thing called "Kaufmännisches Runden", which is kind of cheating as well.
Always depends on which side you're on. If you're getting a refund, it can work in your favor! Importantly, it's a precisely defined rule so that it's not possible to cheat in the implementation.