Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B
by dataflow on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @02:31AM
(#37566314)
> I have read all of it and I don't agree with you. But lets roll with your interpretation.
You don't need to agree with me on what he's saying. The quote "...extra effort to acquire and enable a public IPv6 address" is a directly copied from his own page. It doesn't make sense to read that and claim that's not what he's saying, or to claim I'm "interpreting" it to mean that. There isn't really any other option than to go with that interpretation; that is what he's saying - it's his quote.
> Adding the address to the server is the easiest part of the whole process.
The issue isn't "adding the address to the server". The issue is obtaining said address to be able to add it to the server in the first place. This requires both you and your ISP to set up and manage/maintain an entirely independent parallel network with an entirely separate configuration. It's an administrative hurdle, not merely a technical one. I can't explain it better than this user did, so just read his comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37555424
In any case, it's fine if you disagree that this is actually a significant hurdle; I'm not trying to argue that point. My goal here was to portray what djb is saying accurately, not to agree or disagree with it. So if you disagree with it, that's mission accomplished (for me anyway).
You don't need to agree with me on what he's saying. The quote "...extra effort to acquire and enable a public IPv6 address" is a directly copied from his own page. It doesn't make sense to read that and claim that's not what he's saying, or to claim I'm "interpreting" it to mean that. There isn't really any other option than to go with that interpretation; that is what he's saying - it's his quote.
> Adding the address to the server is the easiest part of the whole process.
The issue isn't "adding the address to the server". The issue is obtaining said address to be able to add it to the server in the first place. This requires both you and your ISP to set up and manage/maintain an entirely independent parallel network with an entirely separate configuration. It's an administrative hurdle, not merely a technical one. I can't explain it better than this user did, so just read his comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37555424
In any case, it's fine if you disagree that this is actually a significant hurdle; I'm not trying to argue that point. My goal here was to portray what djb is saying accurately, not to agree or disagree with it. So if you disagree with it, that's mission accomplished (for me anyway).