Your Brain Is Not An Onion With A Tiny Reptile Inside (2020)

Re:Your Brain Is Not An Onion With A Tiny Reptile Inside (2020) by snek_case on Monday September 18, 2023 @04:10PM (#37561341)

In addition to this... Sure, evolution modifies existing structures, but if you compare a cat's heart and stomach to a pig heart and stomach, the difference is not that big, even though the nearest evolutionary ancestor was tens (hundreds?) of millions of years ago. Once a structure is in place and works well, you can certainly tweak it, but it's easier to mostly just keep it.

Humans have a neocortex, but if you play with a cat or dog, you can recognize and understand the emotions they are feeling. Fear, anger, joy, anxiety, relaxation, etc. That suggests the structures responsible for those things in us are probably not that different from them.

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:Your Brain Is Not An Onion With A Tiny Reptile Inside (2020) by tsimionescu on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @02:16AM (#37566193)

> Humans have a neocortex, but if you play with a cat or dog, you can recognize and understand the emotions they are feeling. Fear, anger, joy, anxiety, relaxation, etc. That suggests the structures responsible for those things in us are probably not that different from them.

And yet birds don't have a neocortex, and yet they share all the same behaviors that mammals share (at least in some species). I don't know if there is some creature with a neocortex that doesn't share all of these behaviors, but at least we can see that the neocortex may be sufficient but is not required for a species to have them.

[ Parent | on HN ]