News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by ta1243 on Monday September 18, 2023 @05:18AM (#37553974)
The existence of NAT66 and NPTv6 are proof that there is still a need for NAT in an ipv6 environment. Maybe not in your environment, but people wouldn't make these solutions if there wasn't a need.
Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by robertlagrant on Monday September 18, 2023 @05:25AM (#37554003)
There's certainly a requirement for them, but it would be good to know what the justification of that requirement was before we know if there's a need. E.g. the justification could be "our SOPs say all network traffic must go through NAT", and if you dig deeper you might find that the SOP was written to save money on IPv4 addresses. That would not indicate a fundamental need.
Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by ta1243 on Monday September 18, 2023 @05:27AM (#37554019)
> There's certainly a requirement for them

Thus proving that ipv6 failed in it's mission to get rid of nat

Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by robertlagrant on Monday September 18, 2023 @05:32AM (#37554052)
I don't think this is a useful thing to say. If I keep trying to fill up my electric car with petrol, and get so annoyed that it keeps spilling on the floor that I pay someone to install a petrol cap and fuel tank, it would be equally silly to say that electric cars failed in their mission to get rid of petrol use.
Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by Retric on Monday September 18, 2023 @05:58AM (#37554202)
NAT works well as an ultra simple firewall. All those ancient IoT devices don’t need to accept traffic from arbitrary addresses, but they may need to communicate with the outside world.

Using a firewall is obviously an option, but why give an IP to something you don’t want accessible by the outside world?

Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by lxgr on Monday September 18, 2023 @11:42PM (#37565371)
> NAT works well as an ultra simple firewall.

There's something that works even better as an ultra simple firewall: An ultra simple firewall!

> why give an IP to something you don’t want accessible by the outside world?

- You might change your mind about it needing to be accessible by the outside world, and if it already has a global address you don't need to renumber everything.

- Addressing and routing aren't the same thing; it can be useful to have globally unique addressing even without global reachability.

Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by Retric on Tuesday September 19, 2023 @06:42PM (#37578051)
Ultra simple firewalls that expose your internal network architecture are less secure than NAT. You simply cannot information about your internal network without risk and there’s zero direct benefit for doing so.
Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by ClumsyPilot on Monday September 18, 2023 @06:23AM (#37554344)
> The existence of NAT66 and NPTv6 are proof that there is still a need for NAT in an ipv6 environment

The existence of fridges with twitter integration proves that there is a need to a Lettice to tweet.

There are all kinds of things that exist, steam-powered motorbike among them. Not all of them exist for the right reasons.

Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by thelastparadise on Monday September 18, 2023 @07:16AM (#37554716)
One such use case: multi wan routing.

Would you rather have a bunch of routers sending out advertisements which every client needs to sort out, or have one consistent multi wan load balancing/failover policy that is transparent to clients?

Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by ta1243 on Monday September 18, 2023 @11:40AM (#37557708)
IPv6 purists think that you can simple have multiple IP addresses on each client, all configured magically, and reconfigured transparently when your ISP changes, with every device somehow knowing via some form of policy deployment (perhaps via dhcpv6) which network to use for a given flow.

That's so much simpler than simple src-natting your clients at the edge of your control and routing your outgoing traffic based on a policy at your natting device /s

Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by elsjaako on Monday September 18, 2023 @07:31AM (#37554815)
There's obviously a need, I didn't deny that. I'm not arguing for ipv6, I just want to learn.

The uses that I found while searching weren't very convincing, I was hoping you could give an example.

Re:AWS IPv4 Estate Now Worth $4.5B by lxgr on Monday September 18, 2023 @11:45PM (#37565382)
Network sharing from a device that has only a single IPv6 /128 address comes to mind.