News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We’re in a productivity crisis, according to 52 years of ... by sottol on Sunday September 17, 2023 @02:38AM (#37542151)
I don't know, seems somewhat convincing on the surface but goes to mix some interesting ideas and facts with appeal to authority via quotes and a many unsubstantiated statements led by those ideas/aforementioned facts.

The one thing I always come back to is that nobody really seems to go into the definition of productivity - it's roughly hours worked to produce something, but the details are always sort of scarce, even from the FED.

I don't know, 1970 is also about where population growth started slowing.

Re:We’re in a productivity crisis, according to 52 years of ... by d4nt on Sunday September 17, 2023 @06:01AM (#37543327)
One problem with productivity as a measure is that it’s measured in $ over time, and $ is an aggregate measure of “how much work are people willing to put in to get this?”. If I spend an hour and charge you $100 for the output, my productivity is 100x more than if I spend an hour and charge you $1. Even if I produced the same thing.

So you could restate the problem as “our ability to make things people want using less and less time is flattening out into a S curve rather that increasing exponentially”. And I would argue that this is to be expected.

Take cars. Ultimately, what I _want_ is to get from point A to point B as quickly and safely as possible, and that’s not getting exponentially better. My 2020 car is way more refined and comfortable than a 1970s model would be, but it’s not an exponential improvement. It has four wheels, five seats, goes at 70mph (the national speed limit) just fine. The Sat-nav is more convenient than the A3 map I used to keep in the back, but it does the same job. Self driving might be a big leap forward. So would a teleport. But so far it’s an incremental improvement on 1970.

In many areas of life, the economy is basically bumping up against the limits of physics and my ability to consume. I have more food than I could ever eat, I have a very nice artificial cave to live in, I can control the temperature, there’s hot and cold clean water, there are no armies marching over the horizon, people generally don’t steal my stuff, I can summon the worlds best musicians and entertainers to perform for me in my home 24/7 if I want to.

There are some exceptions to this. My lifestyle is not evenly distributed to everyone on the planet, and I’d like it to be. My lifestyle currently produces CO2, and I’d like it not to. The big area for improvement is biomedical technology. I’d like to not get cancer, or a cold, or age at all really.

What else do I want? Well, in some ways _that_ has become the defining problem of this era, we don’t know. I want someone to love me, I want people to respect me, I want to feel that my life has meaning and purpose. The economy can attempt to ‘solve’ those problems for me, but it’s a poor substitute. From 1870-1970 we fixed the big problems, things have gotten trickier since then.

Re:We’re in a productivity crisis, according to 52 years of ... by ajmurmann on Monday September 18, 2023 @11:02AM (#37557080)
1973 is also when we had the OPEC oil embargo and we went from a society arranging atoms to more of a focus on arranging bits / doing thought work. Before that productivity scaled with increased energy inputs. At least that's the argument I've heard Noah Smith make and it makes sense