Re:America's advanced manufacturing problem and how to fix it
by 0xDEAFBEAD on Sunday September 17, 2023 @01:06AM
(#37541699)
>A tax on financial transactions. This is sometimes called a "Tobin tax". The US financial services sector has doubled in size as a fraction of the economy. It's currently around 12%. That's an overhead cost, and a big one. Could be half that.
What reason is there to believe that this is an overhead cost?
Taxing financial transactions intuitively seems like the sort of thing which would put a drag on economic growth. And manufacturers need to transact just like any other sort of business; I don't see how taxing transactions encourages manufacturers relative to other firms.
I like the tax on advertising though. I would tweak it so the tax only kicks in once your spending on ads exceeds, say, $10 million per year. That way innovative new products can advertise to customers tax-free. This method also encourages big monopolies to spin-off individual product lines, which could reduce monopoly power.
What reason is there to believe that this is an overhead cost?
As I mentioned in another comment, over the past ~10 years or so, US median earnings have grown remarkably fast compared with other large countries: https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=0xDEAFBEAD
Taxing financial transactions intuitively seems like the sort of thing which would put a drag on economic growth. And manufacturers need to transact just like any other sort of business; I don't see how taxing transactions encourages manufacturers relative to other firms.
I like the tax on advertising though. I would tweak it so the tax only kicks in once your spending on ads exceeds, say, $10 million per year. That way innovative new products can advertise to customers tax-free. This method also encourages big monopolies to spin-off individual product lines, which could reduce monopoly power.