Re:Jefferson and America's Lost Idea: Natural Aristocracy
by zozbot234 on Saturday September 16, 2023 @10:20AM
(#37534984)
Every society can be described in terms of some hierarchy and power structure. In fact seemingly 'structureless' societies tend to be the most tyrannical of all, because power relations simply become opaque. Only very small groups of humans can be said to be genuinely free of any kind of (perhaps ephemeral and shifting, but still real) hierarchy.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Jefferson and America's Lost Idea: Natural Aristocracy
by giaour on Saturday September 16, 2023 @01:30PM
(#37536779)
We seem to be making some variations of the same point here. The implication I was trying to draw out is that in GGP's "natural" aristocracy, there is a separate power structure that maintains that society's shape. That means that the "natural" aristocracy is neither natural nor an aristocracy, since it is artificially maintained and is subordinate to the separate power structure.