News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The mathematical reason why agencies get stuck at $50k MRR by tqi on Friday September 15, 2023 @12:57AM (#37518627)
Seems like the author is just working backwards from a conclusion, picking numbers that "work out" to $50k. Obviously growth plateaus when churn matches new + resurrected, that's just basic growth accounting. Why is $50k such a barrier? Is it even?
Re:The mathematical reason why agencies get stuck at $50k MRR by oefrha on Friday September 15, 2023 @01:13AM (#37518735)
Yeah, they used a bunch of completely random magical numbers: $2k/mo/client, 2 new clients/mo, asymptotic churn rate of 15%. All they’ve demonstrated is there’s likely a ceiling somewhere for each agency, which is obvious to anyone.

Big thumbs down, save yourself the click.

Re:The mathematical reason why agencies get stuck at $50k MRR by sshine on Friday September 15, 2023 @01:30AM (#37518848)
> that’s just basic growth accounting

And a monad is just a monoid in the category of endofunctors.

This stuff is not obvious to everyone. The arbitrary numbers are called an example.

The point of the article is to say, when you experience a plateau and you begin to speculate why, it’s mathematically expectable.

Re:The mathematical reason why agencies get stuck at $50k MRR by manmal on Friday September 15, 2023 @01:37AM (#37518887)
This use of the term math irks me. Math exists within the bounds of its own rules, and often it explains the world well. Sometimes, math can be used to make predictions about the world. But to infer that such a prediction is valid „just because I can make the numbers line up“ is IMO too hand-wavy and maybe even pseudo scientific. I wouldn’t drag mathematical models into this so early in the process.
Re:The mathematical reason why agencies get stuck at $50k MRR by sshine on Friday September 15, 2023 @02:20AM (#37519192)
He’s expanding on how rates grow in proportion.

It can hardly be controversial to call this math.

But you’re right, it’s not “the mathematical reason” but rather “a mathematical explanation” - the math is a property of his explanation, and the reason is growth, churn and employee psychology; while well-explained mathematically, they aren’t math.

Re:The mathematical reason why agencies get stuck at $50k MRR by magicalhippo on Friday September 15, 2023 @04:35AM (#37520140)
Reminds me of our introductory course in math at uni. The lecturer was showing a concrete example of how to integrate using the technique we'd just learned.

After a lengthy manipulation of the integral, he said "and then you can just plug this into a calculator and get an answer, but that's not really interesting so I'll stop here".

Re:The mathematical reason why agencies get stuck at $50k MRR by itiro on Friday September 15, 2023 @05:41AM (#37520559)
Is it common? The point is asserted at the top of the article, but no data is provided to back it.
Re:The mathematical reason why agencies get stuck at $50k MRR by manmal on Friday September 15, 2023 @06:08AM (#37520779)
What I mean is this: Making some anecdotal observations that can be explained by a certain model, doesn't mean the real world follows this model. It might not even be a good approximation.
Re:The mathematical reason why agencies get stuck at $50k MRR by pc86 on Friday September 15, 2023 @08:52AM (#37522173)
It's okay to use specific examples to explain a general principle or to make your point more clearly. But when those examples are more-or-less made up, as they are here, you'd better:

1. Be clear that they're examples and not some fundamental, mathematical truth.

2. Use multiple examples with different numbers to show how things could look different, even if only slightly.

The author does neither of these. #1 is violated in the title. It's not clear at all that the author is using these numbers as merely examples.

Re:The mathematical reason why agencies get stuck at $50k MRR by tqi on Friday September 15, 2023 @10:00AM (#37523068)
It's not obvious that when the number if new customers acquired = customers churned, growth flattens?
Re:The mathematical reason why agencies get stuck at $50k MRR by _rm on Friday September 15, 2023 @04:22AM (#37520059)
It's just concrete numbers to help the reader visualise.

And as a reader who's worked at agencies before, he's right.

The only part he's missing is that most agency owners grind on with this because of personal (psychological) limitations, and thereby get stuck. They get mentally capped out, so they can't move forward, and they form the core of the business, so they can't sell out. All they can do it stay locked in grit-your-teeth mode, until age and/or health fixes the situation for them despite their will.

Agencies cap out very much like this, because of their fundamental scalability issues, but that's also why people enter that market. Easier to enter, because no one person can dominate it like a Google or Facebook.

The number they cap out at is very tied at the intelligence, work ethic, etc, of the founder, but it always caps out in that asymptotic graph kind of way.

The only way I've seen them successfully break out is to know this effect, and to use the cashflow to cover a product company offshoot that gets traction - basically a self-funded startup. But it's a rare case, because they we're attracted to the immediate and certain money lure of agency, vs the valley of death gamble of product.

Re:The mathematical reason why agencies get stuck at $50k MRR by 3np on Friday September 15, 2023 @05:21AM (#37520422)
I also imagine a fair share of owners are actually content enough at ~$50k MMR. If you have expenses under control and not too much staff that can work out to a decent profit/salary.
Re:The mathematical reason why agencies get stuck at $50k MRR by interactivecode on Friday September 15, 2023 @08:01AM (#37521694)
agree. From my experience I’ve also noticed that agencies usually have a shelf life of 10-15 years max. At the start they are the young fashionable agency doing great work. At some point due to a combination of great employees leaving for bigger jobs and the company getting bogged down with stable but boring long term clients, the company dies.

Sometimes they end up cashing out and retiring. Most often they go bankrupt or get bought out by a consultancy looking to brand themselves as fresh.

It’s fun working in ad agencies on the uphill. You’ll be able to do great work and learn how to ruthlessly prioritize quality output. On the downhill it can really corner you with little career growth and little pay.

Re:The mathematical reason why agencies get stuck at $50k MRR by JimDabell on Friday September 15, 2023 @08:45AM (#37522126)
> And as a reader who's worked at agencies before, he's right.

I’ve worked at a load of agencies and I don’t recognise what he's saying at all. What agencies sell $2k/mo packages? They are all either much larger finite projects or they have much larger retainers. What would you even sell for $2k/mo? That’s not going to cover anything beyond absolute basic maintenance to keep the lights on; it’s certainly not where agencies are making their money.

Re:The mathematical reason why agencies get stuck at $50k MRR by pc86 on Friday September 15, 2023 @08:48AM (#37522146)
It's pretty clear by the second sentence of the article that the author has no idea what they're talking about and is just making shit up:

> Hardly anyone ever breaks through that [$50k MRR] barrier and reaches that next level where the agency generates reliably $300k+ in monthly revenue.

Why is $300k the "next level" after $50k? So if I have a $50k MRR business and 5x its revenue, I'm still not at the "next level?" I've never heard a single person say that and they present it as if it's fact and move on.