People who tried to defend themselves with vain word choice now have that very act of defence used as a tool for their prosecution.
But on the other side of the coin very real bullying can come from just words.
Unfortunately what is real bullying and just harmless talk exists actually exists on a gradient so we can't really codify it into anything that seems reasonable. Most good judgements are arrived at by just intuition.
Investigations should start with the crime and work backwards to find the criminal. If you have to find incriminating statements to tell if a crime has even happened, that should really a different thing.
That's what it sounds like:
>Alphabet Inc.’s Google is on trial in Washington DC over US allegations that it illegally maintained a monopoly in the online search business.
They aren't 100% sure so they are finding statements and actions to prove that Google is engaging in anti-competitive behavior.
If you have to use dragnet searches, that means you don't have any clear bad action to work from, and you're trying to construct it from statements.
But for antitrust it's using words to try to show that a crime even happened at all.
That's definitely weirder -- more like if Tom said he killed Fred, but we don't really know who Fred is or whether he is alive or not, and we still put Tom on trial using a series of his statements.
A simple criminal example is would be the difference between negligent homicide, manslaughter and murder. Which can be summed up respectively as lack of intent, lack of intent for outcome and intentional.
To suss this out you’d have to figure out the state of mind of the person in question and going over their communications is one of many ways to do this.
In the context of anti-trust this gets a bit more complicated but in a nutshell that is severely lacking the necessary nuance the difference comes down to getting ahead by legal pro-competitive means and getting ahead by illegal means.
To figure out if a company got ahead just because they had a great product (or got lucky) and based on that they had an organic market growth v. them getting ahead because they had access to means and methods they only derived from their size and market share in other markets, it’s important to look at communications to see what the intent behind decisions was. This becomes increasingly more important when you’re dealing with a behemoth of a company where the lines between different departments and projects are blurred.
All of that is not even touching upon the fact that pretty much everything is an action, or act, even the choice of inaction. Speaking, making a decision, not acting on knowledge, etc. They can all be considered acts.
To sum it up, intent is often a deciding element of an illegal act. But if Google ends up being punished, it isn't because of these communications, it is because of what these communications prove in terms of the acts they are being prosecuted for.
Punishments should be driven primarily from actions and harms, and words should just be used to show intent and involvement.
It seems weird to me that the question of whether company X did something wrong is answered by its own employees' statements (based on their narrow perspective) rather than some objective criteria that something bad happened.