Re:Johnny Decimal: A System to Organize Projects
by PurpleRamen on Thursday September 14, 2023 @09:42AM
(#37508917)
> This is nit-picking the specific example rather than engaging with the GP's point.
It's showing that tags can be fuzzy too. So the initial complaint is not avoided, just moved.
Re:Johnny Decimal: A System to Organize Projects
by giaour on Thursday September 14, 2023 @03:02PM
(#37513278)
Tags (as the comment I was responding to and its parent define them) are allowed to be fuzzy. Categories arranged in a hierarchy do not permit any fuzziness, because things must fall into one category or another (but not both).
This is nit-picking the specific example rather than engaging with the GP's point. There are definitely genres that span the fiction/non-fiction divide (like romance, horror, politics, judaica, and many more). Interestingly, hierarchical systems used by libraries tend to ignore genre. The Dewey Decimal system doesn't classify literature by genre but instead by language, though some overarching genres (drama vs poetry) are treated as subcategories of language (e.g., German poetry is 831, French poetry is 841), but only for major European languages.