Re:'A Test You Need to Fail': A Teacher's Open Letter to Her...
by acdha on Saturday March 24, 2012 @01:17PM
(#3749927)
Everything you mention is technically possible but it's unclear that they are actually well used, with considerable evidence (see NYC's recent data release) that the numbers are used by people who are completely unprepared to work with complex data.
Even the value add comparisons are hard to draw correct conclusions from without more context: a student shows no improvement in math. Did they have a bad teacher, an attendance problem or was it something like being an ESL student who has never received the help needed to understand their classes? That's not the kind of analysis which happens when the tests are effectively a single number which determines careers.
Even the value add comparisons are hard to draw correct conclusions from without more context: a student shows no improvement in math. Did they have a bad teacher, an attendance problem or was it something like being an ESL student who has never received the help needed to understand their classes? That's not the kind of analysis which happens when the tests are effectively a single number which determines careers.