Re:Obama's Clinton Problem: Deregulation made the prosperity...
by j2d2 on Monday November 24, 2008 @12:08PM
(#375029)
I think an honest appraisal would say that Clinton-GOP governance gave us both the prosperity of the 90s and today's crisis.
My thoughts exactly. It's not easy to look at prosperity, before a storm, and identify it's contribution to the storm. But the correlation is interesting enough to make blanket statements regarding prosperity and deregulation subject to no conclusion.
Re:Obama's Clinton Problem: Deregulation made the prosperity...
by byrneseyeview on Monday November 24, 2008 @03:10PM
(#375314)
(An exception is Sarbanes-Oxley, which has been much criticized, but I have not heard anyone blame it for the current financial crisis.)
You've never heard anyone point out that Sarbox raised the cost of being a public company, which increased the number of LBOs, which leveraged the economy and fed the CDO market, which led to the collapse?
I think an honest appraisal would say that Clinton-GOP governance gave us both the prosperity of the 90s and today's crisis. Or that Clinton-GOP governance was largely irrelevant to both.
I honestly don't know enough to demonstrate this empirically, but am suspicious of attempts to assign all credit for good things to policies you like but none of the blame for bad things. As the article says, the Clinton-GOP 90s policies are pretty much still the same policies we have in place to day. (An exception is Sarbanes-Oxley, which has been much criticized, but I have not heard anyone blame it for the current financial crisis.)
As for our President Elect, I think his relationship with the Clintons is a very complex one. At times he was hyperbolic in his praise. But earlier he more or less got Bill to throw a temper tantrum by suggesting that Reagan was a more transformational President than he had been. At other times he made the implication that alternating Bush-Clinton-Bush-Clinton would leave us pretty much in the same place we have been. After Obama secured the nomination and all the Democrats closed ranks is when Obama got all gushy about the Clintons and hyperbolic in his praise.
So I would not put too much stock in remarks about the Clintons to determine Obama's true leanings on specific policy issues.