"How do you know you get this without uniform tests?"
The health or otherwise of our small companies, and the creativeness of artists, musicians, mathematicians, and the vigorousness of our politics.
"And for that matter, what does it even mean?"
It means what it has always meant! It means young adults who can take responsibility for themselves and others and who can act in society. Seriously, there is a level where one has to simply point rather than define (Wittgensteinish argument).
"I just don't see how avoiding careful measurement, clearly stated objects and transparency helps a political system give better results."
Because there are different stakeholders, and each part of your process will be challenged, and interpreted differently by some, and others will 'collapse' the wider concept of education down to a narrow focus on measurable outcomes.
Not sure if I'm making sense here because I'm in a different place I suspect.
They are very simple metrics which completely disregard test scores, a metric I reject.
Gatto has some good things to say about this. So does Neil Postman, in his book "Technopoly."
I must be missing something here.
Children who can think for themselves.
How do you know you get this without uniform tests? And for that matter, what does it even mean?
As for me, I'm well aware of political realities. I just don't see how avoiding careful measurement, clearly stated objects and transparency helps a political system give better results.