The real question is, if you have PayPal stablecoins, do you have the keys, or does PayPal? Can PayPal take your crypto money away or freeze it, as they routinely do with Paypal-controlled accounts? That's what really matters.
So at least it's honest.
> Although Paxos has the ability and the right to freeze all USD Stablecoins tokens
Having the technical ability does not actual grant to them the right, I believe.Of course self-custody is a bit misleading as they are any way IOU notes.
But this token does have code to freeze your balance of itself, an action controllable by the token contract administrators, which is Paypal.
this is seen in other similarly structured stablecoins.
but the fungibility of being an erc20 token means offloading it is very easy too, there would therefore be no limitations on transfer amounts, no delay in having liquidity based on the time of day or day of the week. No need to rely on Paypal’s interest in redeeming the token for cash again, as you could just swap them onchain for something else more liquid or more speculative the instant you wanted.
Yes Paypal can freeze PaypalUSD on an address level.
I like the pressure that crypto infrastructure builds within. The general discrimination against crypto on the regulatory front creates these outcomes that are better than the other custodial system, and ironically more in line with bitcoin’s original anti-leverage ethos.
What’s missing are consumers that are discerning because there are a lot of ineligible and poorly managed crypto offerings.
So the regulators are helping, the criticism against crypto is helping, but the organizations offering well designed and well managed products are not what people gravitate towards.
Paypal USD’s design is okay, in comparison to their fiat offering, but only due to regulators creating more difficult requirements for crypto. It is anti-fragility in action and something crypto enthusiasts have always appreciated about crypto: how it gets more resilient under pressure and can adapt.
Paypal USD as a stablecoin is unremarkable and has the same arbitrary fund freeze capabilities that Paypal always had, but it’s fungibility and addition to the stablecoin space is an improvement.