News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pentagon’s shameful effort to draft mentally disabled men... by cooper_ganglia on Monday September 11, 2023 @10:08AM (#37467502)
Someone who was not physically capable of joining the military before they relaxed the physical requirements may be able to handle the mental load, but not necessarily the physical load. That presents just as many problems and dangers to fellow soldiers as someone with a lower IQ.
Re:Pentagon’s shameful effort to draft mentally disabled men... by wolverine876 on Monday September 11, 2023 @10:14AM (#37467603)
> That presents just as many problems and dangers to fellow soldiers as someone with a lower IQ.

That's a big assumption, and I doubt it applies broadly: Many military jobs do not depend much on physical fitness: Drone pilot, mechanic, truck driver, radar operator. Front line service is only one small part.

Also, it omits the point that less-than-physically-fit can understand the risks, made their own decisions, and also improve their fitness.

Imagine drafting people with physical handicaps - that would be the equivalent of McNamara's horrible program.

Re:Pentagon’s shameful effort to draft mentally disabled men... by NoZebra120vClip on Tuesday September 12, 2023 @11:27AM (#37482726)
Relaxing physical requirements is absolutely mandatory if they expect to give a good shot at recruiting women and putting them in all roles, including combat. It's a rather immutable law of biology that the most physically fit women can't meet the bar of fitness for military men, so we approach the lowest common denominator.
Re:Pentagon’s shameful effort to draft mentally disabled men... by cooper_ganglia on Thursday September 14, 2023 @05:41PM (#37515228)
> It's a rather immutable law of biology that the most physically fit women can't meet the bar of fitness for military men

I honestly have no idea how this thought leads to the conclusion that we need to lower the physical standards for military services, rather than simply disallow any woman who can’t meet them from serving in a combat role. We shouldn’t relax the standards to make it easier for women to join, we should be holding women to the exact same standard as anyone else.

If an individual can’t sling a wounded soldier over their shoulder and carry him, why are we allowing these people to enlist at all, regardless of sex? You can’t start accepting blind people into combat roles just to meet diversity quotas. If you can’t meet the basic standards of sight, you can’t enlist. If you can’t meet the basic physical standards, you can’t enlist. That just makes sense.