Having a REPL open is not the same thing as a notebook, if you feel like that, cool I guess.
That thread is old and Julia can cache compiled code now from 1.9 and onward. However, it can not distribute the cached code(yet).
Writing the fastest possible real-time application in c/c++ has the same principles as in Julia. It's not as shoe-horned as you might believe.
When developing Julia, the developers chose some design decisions that affected the workflow of using the language. If it doesn't fit your needs that's cool, don't use it. If you are frustrated and like to try the language come to discourse, people are friendly.
I know, I'm always "holding it wrong". And that's the problem with julia.
> Having a REPL open is not the same thing as a notebook, if you feel like that, cool I guess.
Both workflows amortize the JIT times away by keeping an in-memory cache compiled code. This makes a lot of smaller scripting tasks untenable in julia. So people chose python instead. That means julia needs a massive advantage elsewhere if they are going to incorporate both languages into their project.
> When developing Julia, the developers chose some design decisions that affected the workflow of using the language. If it doesn't fit your needs that's cool, don't use it. If you are frustrated and like to try the language come to discourse, people are friendly.
This thread was about why julia hasn't seen wider adoption. It's my contention that the original design decisions are a one of the root causes of that.
I just timed vscode with the lsp. From the point I open a 40 line file of the lorenz attractor example, it takes 45 seconds until navigation within that same file works, and the lsp hogs 1 GB of memory. That's 5x the memory of clangd and 20x worse performance; hardly what I would consider a snappy experience.
I have no doubt that julia can be shoe-horned into realtime applications. But when I read threads like this [1], it's pretty clear that doing so amounts to a hack (e.g., people recommending that you somehow call all your functions to get them jited before the main loop actually starts). Even the mitigations you propose, i.e., pre-allocating everything, don't exploit any guarantees made by the language, so you're basically in cross-your-fingers and pray territory. I would never feel comfortable advocating for this in a commercial setting.
[1] https://discourse.julialang.org/t/julia-for-real-time-worrie...