News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:$400M in assets to bankrupt in 45-minutes because of a fa... by Jorge1o1 on Sunday September 10, 2023 @06:53PM (#37460913)
I’ve had to fill out forms for new algorithms / quant strategies with questions like:

- how many orders per minute do you expect to create?

- how many orders per minute do you expect to cancel/amend?

- what’s your max per-ticker position?

- what’s your max strategy-level GMV/NMV?

Etc.

Any one of those questions can be used to set up killswitches.

[edited for formatting]

Re:$400M in assets to bankrupt in 45-minutes because of a fa... by distortionfield on Sunday September 10, 2023 @07:05PM (#37460988)
Sure, but there is always the possibility that then you shut down trading when things _arent_ broken.

There are always two error rates.

Defining behavior is great for retrospective analysis but would you really feel comfortable putting hard cuts into production based on the answers to those questions? I’m genuinely asking, because IME I wouldn’t be.

Re:$400M in assets to bankrupt in 45-minutes because of a fa... by amluto on Sunday September 10, 2023 @09:03PM (#37461655)
That last nine in a trading system uptime has exponentially low value unless you have customers who care quite a lot.

Seriously, suppose you have a truly awesome system making $100B per year of revenue. If you unnecessarily shut down 0.1% of the time, that’s only $100M per year lost, and an 0.1% unnecessary shutdown rate seems pretty high.

Re:$400M in assets to bankrupt in 45-minutes because of a fa... by distortionfield on Sunday September 10, 2023 @09:41PM (#37461868)
> That last nine in a trading system uptime has exponentially low value

IME that last 9 is where all the action happens

> unless you have customers who care quite a lot

All customers care about their trades. I’ve worked with these systems. You can’t treat smaller traders as less-than.

> only $100M

How far removed from the problem do you have to be to think one hundred million dollars is not going to effect anyone?

Re:$400M in assets to bankrupt in 45-minutes because of a fa... by Narkov on Monday September 11, 2023 @12:51AM (#37463016)
> How far removed from the problem do you have to be to think one hundred million dollars is not going to effect anyone?

If $10b is at risk, $100m is not a lot for an insurance policy.

Re:$400M in assets to bankrupt in 45-minutes because of a fa... by amluto on Monday September 11, 2023 @12:56AM (#37463042)
Not all automated trading systems have customers.
Re:$400M in assets to bankrupt in 45-minutes because of a fa... by leaflets2 on Monday September 11, 2023 @01:27AM (#37463234)
A way to add limits when being clueless:

Estimate what a real human can do in a day, and use that as the limits. Verify that the system behaves ok for some time, then scale up the desired trading volume and limits, observe, scale, repeat.

But you don't do it by making a (bad) guess up front and then just leaving it at that.