News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Codename: Obtvse by unalone on Friday March 23, 2012 @09:29AM (#3745017)
I take it you haven't been on Hacker News for very long. I am a designer; one of my pet projects went viral after hitting the top of Hacker News. I've also closed a few blogs after my rants there hit the front page; it seemed to me that garnering hundreds of thousands of views for my eighteen-year-old hissy fits might not be the smartest way to make a name for myself.

Dustin's got a flare for minimalist design: he's good at making things simultaneously simple enough that you can grasp them and loud enough that they stand out. Sometimes I come close to admiring him, but he's so smug for so little reason that I can't appreciate him for his talents. Tim van Damme did the superhero thing first and with a tenth the ego; his http://timvandamme.com/ is better-made than anything Dustin's ever touched, spread further than anything Dustin's ever designed, and he never let it go to his head. He's also capable of designing a web site with more than five elements on it at once.

Simple is nice; elegant is better. Dustin seemingly doesn't aspire to elegance and he's content with simply being popular. I don't begrudge wanting popularity, it was hard for me to stop lusting after, but I do begrudge conflating "people like my style" with "I am a great person who makes great things". I love cocky artists, can't get enough of the Dadaists and Philippe Gaulier and jackass Zen tutors who smack you for saying stupid things; but it's got to be earned.

Dustin recently wrote a post that made the rounds which I admired because he seemed to be saying, "I'm not satisfied with how good I am; I want to be better, and do something worthwhile." He strikes me as a guy trying to do the right thing and going about it the wrong way, and I sympathize with him a whole lot. But his ego is hilarious and way out of proportion with the rest of his work, and I find it endlessly amusing how bad he is at handling criticism, endlessly irritating how certain he is that he doesn't deserve it.

Re:Codename: Obtvse by 54mf on Friday March 23, 2012 @09:53AM (#3745136)
Not to get too meta here, but unalone and I have continued this discussion in email, so I'm not going to bother with a large reply here. In short, I apologized for writing him off so quickly, but disagree with his assessment of Svbtle's elegance.
Re:Codename: Obtvse by obilgic on Friday March 23, 2012 @09:57AM (#3745164)
Forget about closed source, invite only bloging network.

We can not even read HN comments you write ?

Re:Codename: Obtvse by obilgic on Friday March 23, 2012 @09:33AM (#3745041)
You make me wanna hover my mouse over you!

Good insights though.

Re:Codename: Obtvse by dmix on Friday March 23, 2012 @09:49AM (#3745113)
Well said. Most of the discussions are all about whether or not stealing designs is justifiable... and thats really missing the point. /btw welcome back unalone.
Re:Codename: Obtvse by unalone on Friday March 23, 2012 @09:56AM (#3745159)
Thanks! :-)
Re:Codename: Obtvse by quotemstr on Friday March 23, 2012 @03:25PM (#3746754)
> his http://timvandamme.com/ is better-made than anything Dustin's ever touched

I don't see why. The linked site is a generic Apple style ripoff with an annoying and unnecessary swipe action. I've seen hundreds of sites just like it. Am I missing something?

Re:Codename: Obtvse by michael_fine on Friday March 23, 2012 @06:07PM (#3747594)
I don't see the Apple part that you're talking about, but I think that he was the original one who did that, and others took inspiration from him. Or maybe I'm just delusional.
Re:Codename: Obtvse by lusr on Friday March 23, 2012 @09:55AM (#3745149)
Well said. I can't wait until my side project (oops... startup... uh, I mean Rockstarium-ninjai fusion device) goes live and I get to satirize this trend with the site design (up until a point, probably the end of beta; at the end of the day I'm still trying to build a real service and a joke only goes so far). I may even be looking forward to this more than the end product.