News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Async Rust Is A Bad Language by throw10920 on Saturday September 09, 2023 @01:43AM (#37442595)
Pedantry. Later on in my comment I literally say "manage memory for you" - it should be pretty clear that my intent was to talk about a hypothetical language that allowed you to change between use of a borrow checker and managed memory, even if I didn't use the correct wording ("turn off the borrow checker") in that particular very small section of it.
Re:Async Rust Is A Bad Language by lmm on Sunday September 10, 2023 @06:20PM (#37460711)
Bit much to complain about pedantry with how prickly your tone has been in this whole thread. If you only want this functionality for rapid iteration/prototyping, which was what you originally said, then leaking memory in those circumstances is not such a problem.
Re:Async Rust Is A Bad Language by throw10920 on Sunday September 10, 2023 @06:30PM (#37460778)
My tone has been prickly because of pedantry (like this), blind zealotry, and factually incorrect statements.

> If you only want this functionality for rapid iteration/prototyping, which was what you originally said, then leaking memory in those circumstances is not such a problem.

There's pretty obvious use-cases for wanting your language to be productive outside of prototyping, such as scripting (which I explicitly mentioned earlier in this thread[1]), and quickly setting up tools (such as long-running web services) that don't need to be fast, but should not leak memory.

"Use Rust, but turn the borrow checker off" is laughably inadequate.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37441120

Re:Async Rust Is A Bad Language by lmm on Sunday September 10, 2023 @07:41PM (#37461183)
Yeah, I do think the space where manual memory management is actually desirable is pretty narrow - and so I'm kind of baffled that Rust caught on where the likes of OCaml didn't. But seemingly there's demand for it. (Either that, or programming is a dumb pop culture that elevates performance microbenchmarks beyond all reason)