Re:Microsoft will assume liability for legal copyright risks...
by livrem on Friday September 08, 2023 @02:39AM
(#37430246)
Every kind of web crawler has to copy data. If that part of the AI training is illegal for that reason then every web crawler ever is suddenly declared automatically illegal.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Microsoft will assume liability for legal copyright risks...
by graeme on Friday September 08, 2023 @10:07PM
(#37441497)
Web crawlers generally allow sites to remove them from the index.
Are there any crawlers used for commercial purposes which refuse to remove sites from an index if they ask? The distinction from OpenAI is that there is no way to be removed from openai's training set.
You can remove yourself from the crawler not but not from what they previously crawled.
Re:Microsoft will assume liability for legal copyright risks...
by livrem on Saturday September 09, 2023 @06:19PM
(#37450849)
BIf a copy of the downloaded file is redistributed or used in possibly other ways that infringe on copyrights, THAT I could understand, but suddenly making the act of just downloading the file (assuming it is made legally available to the public). But if the downloaded file is analyzed by some software and then thrown away, I don't see how that is infringing copyrights, more than say downloading an image to decompress it and scale it to display on a screen (then throw it away once it is no longer needed).