Re:Viral 'human bird wings' video fake, probably an ad, expe...
by lotharbot on Sunday March 25, 2012 @06:06PM
(#3753992)
If you're looking for heuristics for evidence-weighting, I submit "this story is getting significant votes on HN" should usually be enough to override the low-credibility-score based heuristic you might otherwise use.
Perhaps it is not quite right to say that ignoring it completely is "proper evidential weighting". What I mean is that it is a better heuristic than the ones your brain's native evidence-weighing routines will employ. And since it is impossible to completely override those instinctive heuristics, there is some level of credibility below which the best course of action is to simply disregard a source. The fact that we have limited investigative resources further raises that bar.
Otherwise, I would have to spend all of my time weighing odds and researching the plausibility of claims gleaned from Prison Planet, during which I could learn much more information about the world by focusing my attention elsewhere.
>(The problem with the heavily-downvoted grandparent post is more than mere improper evidential weighting. The larger problem is that it's boring and off-topic. Here on Hacker News, we prefer comments that add value to the discussion.)
Well yes, it just bothers me quite a lot when people act like ignoring disreputable sources is some kind of sin against rationality.