News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bit by bit microplastics from tyres are polluting our wat... by XorNot on Wednesday September 06, 2023 @06:08PM (#37412082)
I operate under the suspicion that there's a lot of fossil fuel astroturfing going on with things like this.

They know full well anything which slows adoption is going to ultimately lead to sustained ICE usage, not some third option.

Re:Bit by bit microplastics from tyres are polluting our wat... by arcticbull on Wednesday September 06, 2023 @06:20PM (#37412191)
Some of us would just rather invest in busses, bikes and trains if we're going to replace everything on the road right now.

The reality is yes of course EVs are better than ICE cars - eventually. It takes some 20-90,000 miles driven for them to break even in terms of CO2 emissions thanks to all the lithium and copper that goes into them. The tire wear is yet another new and interesting challenge.

They're being marketed as a panacea, but they're not. They're probably 1/2 to 1/4 as bad as a gas powered car for most people in most cases. For some people it's worse than a gas car - the ones who get big heavy cars like an electric hummer, or for people who don't put too many miles on their cars.

The best car is the one you don't need because you have public transit around. That way you can use the roads for neat stuff like restaurants, and walking.

Re:Bit by bit microplastics from tyres are polluting our wat... by rootusrootus on Wednesday September 06, 2023 @06:25PM (#37412248)
> 1/2 to 1/4 as bad as a gas powered car

That right there is huge cause for celebration.

> For some people it's worse than a gas car.

Those people should wait, and let someone else use the EV. But for a good comparison, I think we should stick to lifecycle for the car and not individual owners. Few cars go from cradle to grave with only a single owner.

Re:Bit by bit microplastics from tyres are polluting our wat... by arcticbull on Wednesday September 06, 2023 @06:26PM (#37412258)
It's better, it's not best - we know what 'best' is and what it looks like, we're just choosing not to invest in it.

The main issue I have is it's being marketed as something it isn't to placate entrenched interests.

> Those people should wait, and let someone else use the EV.

Why? Why shouldn't both people take a train? Same kind of argument really.

Re:Bit by bit microplastics from tyres are polluting our wat... by rootusrootus on Wednesday September 06, 2023 @06:29PM (#37412284)
Are you suggesting 'best' is public transit? We know already that it doesn't come anywhere close to solving the myriad use cases for private transportation. I'd love a very healthy public transit system, but cars are always going to have their place. Public transit has a halfway decent use case for a good number of people, for sure.
Re:Bit by bit microplastics from tyres are polluting our wat... by arcticbull on Wednesday September 06, 2023 @06:29PM (#37412297)
Each car costs $50-100K right now, times however many cars we're going to replace over the coming few years. Thats 290M * let's call it $75K = $21T. What kind of transit system do you think that would buy us? How much better for the environment do you think that would be?

A transit system like Hong Kong MTR would get us down to 1 in 3 people owning a car. Down from 179% right now. If the rest were gas, so what? Could still swap them out for electric over time.

Re:Bit by bit microplastics from tyres are polluting our wat... by rootusrootus on Wednesday September 06, 2023 @06:54PM (#37412549)
You can buy any of a number of EVs for quite a bit less than 50K. And they'd be replacing an equivalent ICEV that's going to be replaced anyway, for a use case that will not 100% be replaceable by public transit.

Comparing the US to Hong Kong is severely biased. Though it does explain why many people on HN are so delusional about what problems public transit can and cannot solve. Even in Europe, which everyone says has much better public transit than the US, the vast majority of people own cars. They're useful, and denying that just destroys the pro-transit argument before it can even be made.

Re:Bit by bit microplastics from tyres are polluting our wat... by sokoloff on Wednesday September 06, 2023 @07:51PM (#37412984)
The US light duty vehicle (GVW under 7 tons) sales are in the 14-17M/yr range.

The average price is just over $46K.

Multiply and you get around 700B/yr. $21T is 30 years worth, which doesn't match my usage of "coming few years". (That also assumes that all new vehicles could be replaced with transit, which is obviously false for most delivery and service/construction type vehicles, many of which fit into the light-duty segment figures above.)

Re:Bit by bit microplastics from tyres are polluting our wat... by arcticbull on Thursday September 07, 2023 @01:02AM (#37414941)
I was just using the cost to replace all gas cars in the US to frame the magnitude of the conversation.

Honestly what’s cool to me is being able to travel anywhere in America any time I want for a few dollars without owning a depreciating asset I have to pay $1-2000 per month in payments for, a few hundred in insurance, a few hundred in parking and a few hundred in maintenance, a few hundred in gas - plus tickets and tolls. I need all that just to get around the city I live in. Then there’s the 1% lifetime risk of dying in a car accident and the easily order of magnitude higher risk I’ll get injured. For the privilege of being stuck in traffic jams all the time.

That’s indentured servitude, not freedom, and that’s true whether my car is powered by gasoline, electricity or whale oil.

Re:Bit by bit microplastics from tyres are polluting our wat... by XorNot on Thursday September 07, 2023 @06:54AM (#37417139)
Provided you always plan ahead for where you're going by multiple hours. And don't carry anything more then hand luggage. And don't semi-regularly need to move heavy loads. Or need to get children from place to place. And that there's public transport service there at all.

People always have some "look how lightweight my life is, why would anyone need a car" and I can pretty reliably guess that they (1) don't own a house and/or (2) don't have kids, and/or (3) don't work in a job which requires them to get to more then 1 site and/or (4) live near the center of a major urban center.

Finally: "pay for the road you drive on" - that's literally what gas taxes are for, EVs already attract additional taxes to account for this, and I'm real curious how you think the things you buy in stores get there...

Re:Bit by bit microplastics from tyres are polluting our wat... by arcticbull on Thursday September 07, 2023 @08:46AM (#37418123)
> Provided you always plan ahead for where you're going by multiple hours.

I took Hong Kong MTR recently and during peak times they had 40 trains per hour (2 trains every 3 minutes), and off-peak it was like 8 trains per hour.

You really didn't have to plan ahead. It was lovely.

> And don't carry anything more then hand luggage.

Order it delivered.

> And don't semi-regularly need to move heavy loads.

Rent a car when you need it.

> Or need to get children from place to place

Go with them on transit.

> And that there's public transport service there at all.

Which is my point.

> Finally: "pay for the road you drive on" - that's literally what gas taxes are for, EVs already attract additional taxes to account for this, and I'm real curious how you think the things you buy in stores get there...

The entire cost of roads is not born by fuel taxes. Fuel taxes total about $50B but roads generally cost about $200B. Free parking, parking minimums in building, etc, etc, are all taxes non-drivers have to pay to support drivers habits.

Re:Bit by bit microplastics from tyres are polluting our wat... by sokoloff on Thursday September 07, 2023 @07:37AM (#37417475)
> I have to pay $1-2000 per month in payments for, a few hundred in insurance, a few hundred in parking and a few hundred in maintenance, a few hundred in gas - plus tickets and tolls. I need all that just to get around the city I live in.

We have a family of four, two adult drivers and two cars. I haven't had a car payment in years, but let's allocate $250/mo towards replacing cars every 10-12 years or so with another used car. We pay $102/mo in insurance, about $80/mo in gas and $20/mo in electricity, about $60/mo in registration and taxes, and if I budget $200/mo in repairs (one Honda, one EV), I'll have money left over.

One of us needs all of $2-3k/mo for one and the other needs ~$750/mo for two. There's a wide range of what one can spend on motoring versus what one must.

Re:Bit by bit microplastics from tyres are polluting our wat... by arcticbull on Thursday September 07, 2023 @08:45AM (#37418118)
> One of us needs all of $2-3k/mo for one and the other needs ~$750/mo for two. There's a wide range of what one can spend on motoring versus what one must.

I spend $70 per month to go everywhere, whenever I want, with zero tail risk.

Forcing this huge cost on everyone is a regressive burden on the poor.

$750/month for a family's lifetime is easily $450,000. Wouldn't you prefer to retire early, or have an extra half million dollars to leave your kids?

Re:Bit by bit microplastics from tyres are polluting our wat... by sokoloff on Thursday September 07, 2023 @08:53AM (#37418192)
OK, I misunderstood what you meant when you said "I need all that just to get around the city I live in" then.